Donate SIGN UP

Oxford Union

Avatar Image
Khandro | 08:58 Sun 06th Mar 2022 | News
79 Answers
This really is worth a half-hour's watch. Four young, articulate men, stating their views on the war in Ukraine, a real credit to the University (& Britain).

Gravatar

Answers

41 to 60 of 79rss feed

First Previous 1 2 3 4 Next Last

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by Khandro. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Is there a new meaning for barely literate? Ie "doesn't agree with me"
But again - with the State-controlled media feeding false propaganda to the masses...the support may be based in what people believe to be happening rather than what IS actually happening.

Or upon what the state controlled media is telling us. Reports from reliable sources telling us that steady streams of people are leaving the country confirm that there are Russians who do know what's going on and who don't approve.
naomi24

Which sources are those and why would Russians be leaving their country as a sign that they don't approve of the conflict?

Genuinely curious.

There are some points here worth considering too:

https://carnegiemoscow.org/commentary/86013
'ichkeria: "The National Guard of Ukraine issued a list last week,"

I doubt the Russians are labeling their vehicles according to Ukraine desires.
Z is for Zapad, Russian word for West, and V is for Vostok, Russian word for East.

naomi:" Reports from reliable sources telling us "

Now, there's the rub.
“I doubt the Russians are labeling their vehicles according to Ukraine desires.
Z is for Zapad, Russian word for West, and V is for Vostok, Russian word for East. “

Wrong as usual.
Nothing to do with anyone’s wishes
It’s as I said


I don't think the links prove that the war the Ukraine doesn't have have popular support in Russia.

From:

https://www.kcl.ac.uk/how-do-russians-feel-about-the-war-in-ukraine

' The media clampdown means that many are unaware of the full scale of what is happening there, and see developments from a very different perspective.'

I think that's the bigger problem - Russia is blocking access to international news media and social media and Putin popularity is remaining relatively stable (and high).

//I don't think the links prove that the war the Ukraine doesn't have have popular support in Russia. //

That isn't what I said.
Here's what the letters mean:

Z - Russian forces from the east
"framed" Z - forces from Crimea
O - forces from Belarus
V - marines
X - Chechen
A - special forces
Question Author
sp;

'As of 2015 Internet access in Russia is available to businesses and to home users in various forms, including dial-up, cable, DSL, FTTH, mobile, wireless and satellite. As of July 2018 114,920,477 people (80.86% of the country's total population) were Internet users.'
Wikipedia

How is Putin blocking that?
Not blocking the internet but certain users and organiusations.

A hopeful sign is that the FSB is not happy: the Times reports a whistleblower as admitting Russian casualties indeed may be 10,000 already (several columns were knocked out this morning)
They weren't told in advance of the war, and it was also reported that elements in that organisation had thwarted attempts on Zelensky's life.
naomi24

The invasion has popular support in Russia possibly because of a new and social media blackout and possibly because Russians see the Ukraine and former Slavic nations as being part of Russia.

If Russians think that NATO presence on their doorstep is a genuine threat then they'd think the war is justified.

The numbers fleeing the country do prove that there are some that know what's going on an don't approve but that still doesn't mean that Putin's actions don't have popular support.

The Russian population is just shy of 150,000,000. There would have to be a significant number of protesters/emigrants to prove that the war did not have popular support.
*news not new
//that still doesn't mean that Putin's actions don't have popular support. //

Which bit of 'that isn't what I said' don't you understand?
Just to repeat:
The Russian public largely either don’t know what Putin’s actual actions are, or are protesting in their thousands and being arrested or are against but understandably not wanting to risk arrest.
The numbers who know what is going on AND support this are vanishingly small I’d say.
Hence the crackdown at home
ichkeria

Yep...I think you've hit the nail on the head there. I wonder what the situation would be if the were *no* new blockout though. Would the war be broadly supported?

And what happens when sanctions begin to bite?

No idea why I can't type the word 'news' today.

41 to 60 of 79rss feed

First Previous 1 2 3 4 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

Oxford Union

Answer Question >>