Donate SIGN UP

Are They Really Worth It?

Avatar Image
NellieMay | 13:19 Tue 02nd Jul 2019 | News
55 Answers
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-48826586

Personally, I would like to see some fresh 'talent?' across the presenting spectrum. Rylan Clark-Neal has been a breath of fresh air. And new presenters would save the BBC a fortune!!
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 20 of 55rss feed

1 2 3 Next Last

Avatar Image
In answer to the OP - an unequivocal 'No'! I've never seen all but one of them on TV - or heard them on radio. Having done a bit of research I'm baffled about what Claudia W actually does, never mind the others. Gary Lineker - I simply can't stand him, using his fame to make political points ( I've not bought Walkers crisps for years because of him). Unacceptable...
21:53 Tue 02nd Jul 2019
I’m fed up with seeing Gary Lineker‘s mug on the telly.
if i pared down the list of presenters/commentators/pundits at wimbledon, the bbc would probably be able to afford reinstating free tv licences for pensioners ...
Fiona Bruce must off-shore her earnings not to be on that list.
Who's Jason Mohammed?
I'm not sure what Gary Lineker does to earn so much money. I've got nothing against the bloke but I've no idea why he tops that list.
Weekend work, ludders.
Nor me.
All those different programmes but I've never heard of him.
Fiona Bruce - £255,000-£259,999

Quantifying the worth of someone like this is notoriously difficult.

One of the issues the BBC has is keeping its presenters from being lured away by higher salaries in the commercial sector.

Of course, many people would argue that lots on the list would be no loss, but the ability to appeal to a huge and diverse national audience, which is what the BBC's presenters must do, is a nebulous
concept at best.

Radio and TV has gone the way of football, ludicrous salaries disproportionate to either talent or output, but everyone is on the merrygoround, with no sign of it slowing down.



Question Author
I would be really happy if Claudia Winkleman were to disappear from our screens. I really can't see any talent or entertainment value there at all.
//I would be really happy if Claudia Winkleman were to disappear from our screens//

You can catch her on the radio instead!!

I certainly have an issue with certain female radio presenters especially Zoe Ball but also Sara Cox and Jo Whiley.

I've said it before but it's worth reiterating that broadcasting is a honed skill and it is commonly assumed that ex players in sport, for example, make good broadcasters. Very frequently they don't but they make more appeal to the masses. This could be that they have more charisma or personality but there is far more to it than that. It is about timing, asking the right questions and appearing to listen properly. Knowing when to speak and when not to, etc.

I despair more and more when I hear more and more dross from overpaid and often promoted people well above their abilities.

I don't think they are worth it.
I also think that the BBC should have it's wings severely clipped or be scrapped altogether.
By a country mile NO.
Of course celebrities aren't worth it. It's a prime example of a capitalist society flaw. You end up paying more for entertainment than is reasonable since there is no one offering alternative, so the media companies can overpay individuals claiming that they have to, and the undeserving thus exploit you to become wealthy at your expense. And if a salary difference is uncovered, it's rare enough that the higher one drops to the lower, and never the case that both agree to accept a reasonable, reduced salary instead. It's an insane world.
Obviously these presenters are not worth it.
Neither are pop singers, or actors or newspaper columnists like Boris Johnson who earns £250,000 from the Daily Telegraph for a weekly OP.
The people paying these people think they bring value to their products which is beyond average pay. Certainly, BBC1 is a brilliant channel and an highly valuable asset. And Taylor Swift is a valuable commodity to her label. Hollywood A listers can make or break a film. And your Littlejohns and Hitchens encourage a loyal readership.

So no, they are not worth the money, but in their own way, they bring credibility to the products they work for.
As was said earlier, why are so many commentators needed for events? I’m just watching tennis and there are 3 of them. Why?
Overpaid? Most definitely.
Also I used to love watching Moira Stewart and Trevor MacDonald read the news.
Now I am fed up seeing so many black and Asian faces reporting the news, and taking over the dramas, Holby and Casualty for example. This is Britain, supposedly.
/// Boris Johnson who earns £250,000 from the Daily Telegraph ///

£250,000 - that's chicken feed.

https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-britain-johnson-chickenfeed/london-mayor-calls-250000-pounds-chicken-feed-idUKTRE56D54U20090714
Still not racist though, eh, Theland.....?

1 to 20 of 55rss feed

1 2 3 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

Are They Really Worth It?

Answer Question >>