Donate SIGN UP

Too many public school medal winners?

Avatar Image
DaisyNonna | 21:27 Sun 05th Aug 2012 | ChatterBank
22 Answers
What do people expect? From the very first state school children are positively encouraged not to outdo their classmates. School sports are "everyone is a winner". P.E. in secondary schools teachers are expected to teach other subjects, not just specialise in P.E. Most first and middle school children have P.E. taught by their class teacher, not a specialist.
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 20 of 22rss feed

1 2 Next Last

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by DaisyNonna. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Why should it matter how our athletes were educated? Or what type of background they come from?
do you have a break down of the figures to base an opinion on, gossip won't cut it
I couldn't care less whether they're from public school, private school, borstal or whatever. Where have you heard people making this observation (I deliberately refrain from using the word criticism)
I agree with you DN - I inferred this on the Greatest Ever Day for British Sports thread - arguing that this is exactly the target area for the legacy of the Games, idenitifcation of raw talent, resources both in fields/gyms/pools whatever and coaches....and volunteers. If the PS argument is correct, thank god we have them to kick start the government again - Atlanta was the first wake-up for John Major et al; now for Round 2.
Did you see the 400 metre winner................she looked like a second class hooker.
lol Craft...
Most of the gold medallists of yesterday didn't go to a public school from what I know, Jessica Ennis, Mo Farrar, Greg Rutherford and a fair few of the rowers. Victoria Pendleton didn't either.

I can understand some of the events which are more usual amongst public school educated children, equestrian, shooting, rowing etc...

At the end of the day though, you either have the talent or you don't, of course it's hard work, training and discipline to get there but there needs to be something there to start with and that can't be bought like a public school education.
Straight to the point as usual Crafty. Must have a look.
Also, if someone shows promise it is unlikely they will just practice at school PE class level and will be directed to the appropriate club etc... to get the appropriate training and guidance.
Interesting take on this here:

http://www.guardian.c...ray-state-school-myth

"the total number of British pupils taking part in competitive sport at their school was 78% for the years 2009-10, up from 58% in 2006-07, and the average secondary school now offers participation in around 25 sporting disciplines."
Question Author
Jenna, by whom?
I only went to ormskirk grammar school but our head boy was in some kind of olympic games competition, long jump i think, geoff hignett he was called, his sister was in my year
What does it matter which school? Don't be thinking that Public School is the only breeding ground for everything, from Politicians to captains of Industry and now sport. No-one can ignore raw talent when they see it. We were not taught to stand back politely to let someone else win, anyone with any athletic leaning was encouraged to appear in large events to be recognised then given the training to advance further.
All sorts of people, parents, teachers, friends, themselves, depends on the discipline but talent is likely to get noticed as not many people have potential olympian skill.

When I was younger I enjoyed and had skills in dance, drama and music so I went to a dancing and drama school and had music lessons and played in school orchestras, choirs, did shows etc... If you were good you would be sent to join or audition for higher external groups or specialist schools eg ballet school.

We had all sorts of things on locally during half terms and summer holidays where you could go and try different activities and I tried all sorts including things like rowing. All free or nominal cost. Maybe you could say what if people don't make the effort and don't want to get out and get active but that in itself is not the best indication of someone who will become an olympic champion.
Derek Redmond went to a secondary school I taught at (before I started there) - the head of PE told him he was rubbish at running.
Public school?

Daley Thompson, Linford Christie, Jessica Ennis, Sally Gunnell, Allan Wells, Steve Ovett, Tessa Sanderson, Victoria Pendleton, Bradley Wiggins, Sir Steve Redgrave, Christine Ohuruogu, Andy Murray, Dame Kelly Holmes, Denise Lewis etc etc.

All won gold medals at the Olympics, all are British, yet none went to public schools, so you're talking rubbish.
craft1948
Did you see the 400 metre winner................she looked like a second class hooker.

Are you serious? I just saw the awards ceremony...she looked pretty normal to me.
Question Author
Not me talking rubbish. Government minister.

1 to 20 of 22rss feed

1 2 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

Too many public school medal winners?

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.