News2 mins ago
Oxford Union Debate
Should these speakers have been invited?
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/educa tion/article2948623.ece
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/educa tion/article2948623.ece
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by naomi24. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Yes, free speech is sacred. The debate will allow others to disagree with them. Every person has a right to express their views without violence. Just because we may not agree with their views they have a right to say it otherwise we could be in the situation where that school teacher cannot even put a name to a teddy without being locked up.
There was no obligation to ask Irving and Griffin to speak at an event merely because they happen to know something about free speech. Irving and Griffen weren't clamouring at the door to speak, they were invited. Free speech does not mean any group is *obliged* to invite *anyone*.
Equally however, having invited these two gentlemen, they must be allowed to speak, otherwise freedom of speech means nothing.
Equally however, having invited these two gentlemen, they must be allowed to speak, otherwise freedom of speech means nothing.
It's a brilliant idea.
I mean that seriously. Griffin and the rest of the white supremacist mime-readers will be challenged by the brightest minds in the country.
They never have a real chance to have their views challenged in a civilized debate, and this would give them an opportunity to be 'hoisted by their own petards'.
Next, they should invite some radical Muslim clerics and give them the same treatment.
I'd buy tickets to both events.
I might even bring my own popcorn.
I mean that seriously. Griffin and the rest of the white supremacist mime-readers will be challenged by the brightest minds in the country.
They never have a real chance to have their views challenged in a civilized debate, and this would give them an opportunity to be 'hoisted by their own petards'.
Next, they should invite some radical Muslim clerics and give them the same treatment.
I'd buy tickets to both events.
I might even bring my own popcorn.
Absolutely! I hope someone films it, and we all get to see it. It may not be pleasant to most people to hear what they have to say, but it would be interesting to hear the debate. I do not know much at all about Irving. But I have heard a lot of the statements that Griffin has made. I have never seen him in a debate though, were people can question or refute his statements on the spot. if we want to keep the the privelige of freedom of speech in this country then we must allow everyone the right to say whatever they like no matter how unpleasant it is. But the PC brigade are in the process of destroying this right.
The only way you can challenge someone's views is allow them to make them, and for intelligent people to argue against them.
I've never seen BNP leaders interviewed extensively on television because TV execs are terrified of a public backlash (cf. Shilpa Sheppy).
It would be brilliant if a debate could be set up between the Jewish anti defamation league, the Anti Nazi League and the BNP.
Remember how ridiculous the Tories made themselves look when they banned the Sinn Fein?
I say let the BNP voice their policies. Let them be scrutinized. I'd wager that the majority of people with even the most basic analytical skills will see exactly what the BNP are. It would be the biggest PR own goal since Gerald Ratner made that comment.
I've never seen BNP leaders interviewed extensively on television because TV execs are terrified of a public backlash (cf. Shilpa Sheppy).
It would be brilliant if a debate could be set up between the Jewish anti defamation league, the Anti Nazi League and the BNP.
Remember how ridiculous the Tories made themselves look when they banned the Sinn Fein?
I say let the BNP voice their policies. Let them be scrutinized. I'd wager that the majority of people with even the most basic analytical skills will see exactly what the BNP are. It would be the biggest PR own goal since Gerald Ratner made that comment.
