Donate SIGN UP

Antiques Road Show

Avatar Image
roseandlily | 21:25 Sun 30th Oct 2016 | TV
48 Answers
It's really annoying Fiona Bruce keep saying "The" Flying Scotsman.. the engine is Flying Scotsman..you wouldn't say "The" Mallard or "The" Leander.. should maybe have done a little more research.
Gravatar

Answers

21 to 40 of 48rss feed

First Previous 1 2 3 Next Last

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by roseandlily. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Knowing about steam engines has nothing to do with grammar.
The Flying Scotsman is only stressing it's definitive reputation as opposed to any old scot that is male and flying..nowt to do with knowledge about steam engines
Zacs - nobody's venting off, just giving a view which is what was asked for.
I was addressing the OP dear heart.
Sorry Zacs, thought you were meaning my 2230 offering.
I once visited Sir Nigel Gresley.
"don't think it matters do you really ???...

Well it does matter a little. If you see the locomotive the nameplates clearly say "Flying Scotsman". Similarly many locomotives are not prefixed by "The". It does seem to flow better, though if you say "I saw the Flying Scotsman today" than if you said "I saw Flying Scotsman today". But this seems to be one of the few instances where that might be so. As roseandily says. it would not seem quite so flowing if applied to other examples. Maybe it's because of te loco's fame.

There are a very few locomotives where "The" included properly in the name. I can think of a few steam locos offhand. Two are LNER Class V2s, both with tidy names: No 60809 "The Snapper, The East Yorkshire Regiment, The Duke of York's Own" and No 60835 "The Green Howard, Alexandra, Princess of Wales's Own Yorkshire Regiment". Others include BR Standard "Britannia" class No 70048 "The Territorial Army 1908-1958". A couple of "Standard Arthurs" were named "The Green Night" and "The Red Knight". A few of the 22 "Deltic" (Class 55) Diesel locomotives also spring to mind: "The Kings Own Yorkshire Light Infantry", "The Green Howards", The Duke of Wellington's Regiment" and "The Black Watch" are those I can think of.

"...there is only one after all"

Not strictly true. Although there is only one loco bearing the name there are three "Flying Scotsmen". As well as the loco there is the train (For many years the 10:00am Kings Cross to Edinburgh and the balancing down service). This was often pulled by th eloco of the same name but the service was shared amongst a number of "Top Link" locos and also by Deltic locos after steam was replaced. There is also the Route of the Flying Scotsman which is currently run by Virgin East coast trains.

I really must try to get out more but I'm rehearsing for my part as "The Fat Controller in "Thomas The Tank Engine - The Movie"
No probs Dave. A constant and inherent problem on forums.
only one in service I believe ??
NJ If you miss out on that position you may be able to take over when 'Brackett' retires in Chigley.
The National Railway Museum refers to the engine without the definite article and that's good enough for me.
https://twitter.com/railwaymuseum/status/792666103101136896
Do you mean National Railway Museum?
Ha!
That's it then, job done.
There are people in the world being slaughtered, homeless due to earthquakes, starving or maybe fleeing from their country. ...... And there other people debating when to use the definite article.
Has Answerbank got the answer for earthquakes, slaughter and so on? Reasons for the definite article may be the best answers you'll get.
I wasn't suggesting we have answers for the troubles of the world, but rather that we - healthy, well fed, comfortable, unthreatened as we live, waste time debating inconsequential trivia.
"There are people in the world being slaughtered, homeless due to earthquakes, starving or maybe fleeing from their country. ...... And there other people debating when to use the definite article. "

And...???
Did everyone enjoy the programme from train then?
And - nothing New Judge. Carry on. It is all so important after all.

21 to 40 of 48rss feed

First Previous 1 2 3 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

Antiques Road Show

Answer Question >>