scotland

[laurasand]

Do you think it's a good idea that Scotland become's independant?

[jackthehat]

No.

[Sqad]

Who for...the Scots or the English?

[thistles]

I am Scottish, I say NNNNOOOOOO

[Baldric]

From South of the Border...........YES

[Nibble]

Whatever our wishes and opinions on this matter, unfortunately, under the T&C's of the upcoming referendum on Scottish Independance, or lack thereof,depending on the result, we'll have no input to the matter, so Our opinion is hot air, and is of no relevance.

[wardlaw]

I cannot think why any right-minded Scotsman or woman would vote in favour of the proposal of a glib megalomaniac. The United Kingdom should remain exactly that.

[Banffer]

no

[jamesnan]

Alex Salmond just wants power! the man is power mad

[coccinelle]

I wonder if they did become independant they'd be no longer seen as 'English' by the rest of Europe....

[craft1948]

I feel sorry for the Scots if they do get independence................although maybe I'll get a pension increase.

[Nibble]

Never been called English anywhere in Europe, well at least after they've seen my passport :)

[wolf63]

I wonder if they did become independent they'd be no longer seen as 'English' by the rest of Europe This is guaranteed to upset any Scot.

I don't think that full independence would be a good idea. We are seen as a nation by most people worldwide - and we are universally loved (apart from the people/English people who feel that we are the cause of all that is wrong with their country).

[Wharton]

Should Scotland become independent it will be interesting to see where England/Wales/Northern Ireland park their nuclear submarines.

[tonyav]

I think they may live to regret it Scotland's Independence.

[Just-Jude]

It won't be worth it now. The English have stolen all their oil and water. The Scottish banks had to bailout the English treasury, so there's no money left.

10 years too late!

[commoner]

I'm English and wouldn't want to lose a part of Britain...don't think it would be good for Scotland either...all English don't hate Scots and Scotland Wolf and there is much wrong with England at present that has nothing to do with Scotland....The EU being the biggest problem IMO.... I have always felt British but will never feel European in the same way....

Only one thing wrong with Scotland...the midges are not as welcoming as the Scots when I come on holiday...Ouch!

[daffy654]

The Scottish banks did not bail out the English treasury and we haven't stolen all the oil and gas (why you put water is beyond me).

[wardlaw]

I am very afraid that if it is decided to allow 16 and 17 year olds to vote they will help Soapy gain thousands of 'Braveheart' crosses on ballot papers giving him exactly what he wants - his name the annals of Scottish history for all time.

[commoner]

You mean for messing up Scotland for all time Wardlaw?

[wardlaw]

EXACTLY comoner