Do You Agree Jeremy Clarkson Is Sexy...
Body & Soul5 mins ago
Uk Troops Cleared Of Killing Iraqi Civilians
17 Answers
http://
This is great news, although it as cost the British taxpayer £22m.
/// Last night Colonel Richard Kemp, who commanded UK forces in Afghanistan, said: ‘Many in Iraq and Afghanistan have sought to discredit British soldiers for political purposes or have made claims for personal financial gain. ///
/// ‘In some cases, these people have been wittingly or unwittingly looking to turn a quick buck at the expense of our fighting troops ///
/// Phil Shiner’s Public Interest Lawyers the Birmingham-based firm has alreday been paid millions from the public purse. ///
/// Mr Shiner, 57, has made his name pursuing British soldiers through the courts over alleged war crimes in Iraq. ///
/// He was awarded the title ‘Human Rights Lawyer of the Year’ in 2004. ///
/// On his firm’s website, his profile reads: ‘Phil is a committed socialist ///
Now there's a surprise.
This is great news, although it as cost the British taxpayer £22m.
/// Last night Colonel Richard Kemp, who commanded UK forces in Afghanistan, said: ‘Many in Iraq and Afghanistan have sought to discredit British soldiers for political purposes or have made claims for personal financial gain. ///
/// ‘In some cases, these people have been wittingly or unwittingly looking to turn a quick buck at the expense of our fighting troops ///
/// Phil Shiner’s Public Interest Lawyers the Birmingham-based firm has alreday been paid millions from the public purse. ///
/// Mr Shiner, 57, has made his name pursuing British soldiers through the courts over alleged war crimes in Iraq. ///
/// He was awarded the title ‘Human Rights Lawyer of the Year’ in 2004. ///
/// On his firm’s website, his profile reads: ‘Phil is a committed socialist ///
Now there's a surprise.
Answers
1 to 17 of 17
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by anotheoldgit. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Would it be anti-British, 3T, to point out that the MoD brought this on themselves? The MOD made "serious breaches of its duty", and was accused of a lamentable failure in its duty of candour in its failure to disclose crucial information about the bodies and wounded enemy combatants taken from the battlefield,in findings of 3 High Court judges back in 2004.
It was this action - collecting bodies and wounded of iraqi insurgents from the battlefield and carting them off to their own military compound/hospital -that fuelled the suspicion of family and relatives and lead to charges of murder and ill-treatment being levied by the families at the UK Military.
This collection of the dead bodies of enemy combatants was unprecedented, as I understand it.
I am glad that the allegations were unfounded - I would hate to think that British troops were murdering insurgents after the fact, but this could have been cleared up much sooner had the MoD been more forthcoming.
It was this action - collecting bodies and wounded of iraqi insurgents from the battlefield and carting them off to their own military compound/hospital -that fuelled the suspicion of family and relatives and lead to charges of murder and ill-treatment being levied by the families at the UK Military.
This collection of the dead bodies of enemy combatants was unprecedented, as I understand it.
I am glad that the allegations were unfounded - I would hate to think that British troops were murdering insurgents after the fact, but this could have been cleared up much sooner had the MoD been more forthcoming.
This is from the Wiki page about his death.
The report called his death an "appalling episode of serious gratuitous violence".[2] The inquiry condemned the Ministry of Defence for "corporate failure" and the regiment for a "lack of moral courage to report abuse".[6]
And here's a link to that page.
http://
The report called his death an "appalling episode of serious gratuitous violence".[2] The inquiry condemned the Ministry of Defence for "corporate failure" and the regiment for a "lack of moral courage to report abuse".[6]
And here's a link to that page.
http://
You might round up wounded enemy combatants, as they might represent a future threat - I do not know if that would be covered in the rules of engagement. But taking the allegedly dead combatants off the field? That is unprecedented and was not covered by the MoDs own rules at the time. Had they been more forthcoming earlier, more transparent, they may have allayed the fears of the relatives, the suspicion that some of those described as dead were injured and later killed in cold blood.
Based upon this, it seems to me that an investigation was warranted, because being British we uphold values of fairness and the rule of law, and to carp about the cost is meaningless. If these things have any value in our society, then we have to pay for them.
Based upon this, it seems to me that an investigation was warranted, because being British we uphold values of fairness and the rule of law, and to carp about the cost is meaningless. If these things have any value in our society, then we have to pay for them.
-- answer removed --
-- answer removed --
-- answer removed --
DB
Indeed, I am happy that our troops have been exonerated by a proper legal process.
A process that couldn't have taken place with such validity without the members of the legal profession.
Of course my questions were ridiculous; sorry, but that was because they were challenging your ridiculous parody of lawyers and attempts to directly compare totally different situations between the legal and surgical professions
Indeed, I am happy that our troops have been exonerated by a proper legal process.
A process that couldn't have taken place with such validity without the members of the legal profession.
Of course my questions were ridiculous; sorry, but that was because they were challenging your ridiculous parody of lawyers and attempts to directly compare totally different situations between the legal and surgical professions
-- answer removed --
I did
You suggested lawyers didn't 'really care' about clients
Compared with which professions then? if not surgeons?
You also suggested surgeons don't 'find mugs' to pay them millions. I think you'll find many surgeons are paid millions. Made up of smaller amounts from people they provide a service for of just a few hours. Lawyers paid millions by one individual (not a common occurrence) generally work for many months to do so
You suggested lawyers didn't 'really care' about clients
Compared with which professions then? if not surgeons?
You also suggested surgeons don't 'find mugs' to pay them millions. I think you'll find many surgeons are paid millions. Made up of smaller amounts from people they provide a service for of just a few hours. Lawyers paid millions by one individual (not a common occurrence) generally work for many months to do so
-- answer removed --
1 to 17 of 17
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.