Scotland or New York

[Glpblondie]

So its my boyfriends 30th birthday in January and I wanted to do something really special for him as he's had a really crap year this year. I asked him if he would like to go away somewhere and he said he fancied going to Scotland. I like Scotland (but in all honesty we live up noth anyway so could go whenever we liked), but wanted to make it an exciting and memorable experience so I have booked 4 nights in New York (he's never been). He won't even know about it until we get to the Airport. From a guys angle (and girls) what would you think when you found out that you weren't going to Scotland?

[Bobbisox]

yes, thumbs up for Scotland too, very nice but you can go there anytime

[craft1948]

Redman is lying.......I'm a Tesco's girl.

[karenmac60]

Yogi, where was the wedding? I'm guessing it would've been either Cameron House, The Cruin or the Lodge on the Loch at Luss. All lovely places. I got married on the Maid of the Loch - big boat that doesn't sail :)

[steg]

being Scottish, i would be a bit p'd off if i thought i was going to gods country and ended up in NY

[mazie]

Go for afternoon tea at The Waldorf Astoria

[beastmonkey]

normlly stay at thewaldorf, it is magnificent, now feel foolish i went to the mandarin for afternoon tea, when could have got it at my hotel. doh

bull and bear does great steaks though

[yogi-bear]

Hi Karen,

Sorry for the delay in replying, my lovely......i've been multi-tasking and out a bit.

It was here, as you mentioned.....what a fab place it is.......so picturesque.

http://www.loch-lomond.co.uk/

I bet you have some great memories from your special day you got married, Karen...........and so you should, sweetheart. :0)

All the best yogi xx

[karenmac60]

That's where I spent my wedding night Yogi :) I live 5 minutes walk from the Loch, I probably don't appreciate it as much as I should most of the time.

[Greedyfly]

New York every time for me. But I have never been there and I am not a big fan of the UK. Although I do very much like what I have seen of Scotland so far. If you think he will enjoy it then spoil him.

[bobbie22]

go to New York its fabulous, such a buzz!!!!