England Test match Victory?

R1Geezer | 15:21 Mon 20th Jul 2009 | Sport

33 Answers

OK which of you anti English yoghurt knitters will be the first to explain why it isn't a "proper" win? You can usually find a reason to devalue or denigrate an England win, in any sport! So do your worst!

sportsmen

Names on both honours boards

Answers

1 to 20 of 33

1 2 Next Last

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by R1Geezer. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.

redman41

We're 1 Up in the Series si I'm happy so far !!!!

joggerjayne

Have we won?

redman41

We have indeed Jogger ! Roll on next Test

-- answer removed --

craft1948

I love Freddie......

joggerjayne

Fab !!

Wooo Hoooooooo

I might be going to my first "proper" Cricket match on Saturday.

Sussex against (somebody unimportant), at Lord's !!

-- answer removed --

redman41

Well done Vibrasphere ! You are on top at present whilst I'm on the way down !! LOL
3 Tests to go for the Wooden Spoon so we'll have to knock you off the Top !!!!!!!!!!

TCL-MUMPING

Ricky Ponting's being out "caught" springs to mind...

redman41

Agree with you TCL-MUMPING as there will always be controversial decisions made. There will be dubious decisions made in the next Test as well. It happens in all Sport unfortunately but it adds to the debate.
R1Geezer wants us to moan, but I for one are quite happy with the result !!

TCL-MUMPING

I think I'm right in saying that the third umpire can rule on matters of fact, ie not on LBW's for example and can rule on boundaries and catches. Why then could he not say Ponting did not hit the ball?

R1Geezer

Question Author

Ponting hit the ball and it was caught, look in the paper tomorrow, Anyway TCL you get the BGB for this question.!

sqad617

Don't get too excited....good win....YES.

Bottom line:

Both teams are equally matched.
Our bowlers are better than their bowlers.
Their batsmen are better than our batsmen.

3 more tests to go.

redman41

Don't forget Squad, they have Brett Lee to come back into their Bowling attack! Start of next Test 30th july so roll on.

TCL-MUMPING

I'm on about the First Innings, yes he hit the ball but it was his foot and not the bat. Look in the PREVIOUS days' papers...

sqad617

redman...good point

TCL....I agree, but a couple of LBW decisions went their way.

TCL-MUMPING

The difference between an LBW and a catch is one is an opinion and the other is a fact (albeit sometimes based upon the honesty of the batsman or fielder.) Even Hawkeye is based on a program using assumptions. If a replay clearly shows a ball has not struck the bat, why not use the technology?