Tv Charity/Charity Lottery Adverts.
ChatterBank1 min ago
Smoking, when will.....
...this disgusting habit finally be consigned to history?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7771210.stm do you think this latest initiative will help? I know that smoking is being actively encouraged in 3rd world countries/eastern bloc etc so do you think that's just the death throws of an industry or are we in danger of having a non smoking western world being shocked by this "strange" habit when they visit up and comming nations? it's almost getting to the stage now for me when I see someone in the street smoking I get a sort of "How strange" feeling!
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7771210.stm do you think this latest initiative will help? I know that smoking is being actively encouraged in 3rd world countries/eastern bloc etc so do you think that's just the death throws of an industry or are we in danger of having a non smoking western world being shocked by this "strange" habit when they visit up and comming nations? it's almost getting to the stage now for me when I see someone in the street smoking I get a sort of "How strange" feeling!
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by R1Geezer. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Yeah, i cant wait until smoking is banned outright.....and then see the government hike up every tax they can, and maybe invent a few new ones, as they wont be getting anything out of the smokers.
Think of it this way - i was in Tenereife a month or two ago.
A pack of 20 smokes cost me around about �1.75.....for the same pack of smokes over here, it's about �5.15.
If �3.40 of ever pack of tabs is going to the government, what do you think is going to happen when there is a complete stop to it??
I'll be waiting for the "oh, increased taxes wont bother me" argument, but i guarentee, every single tax payer will be up in arms at having to pay so much more!!
Think of it this way - i was in Tenereife a month or two ago.
A pack of 20 smokes cost me around about �1.75.....for the same pack of smokes over here, it's about �5.15.
If �3.40 of ever pack of tabs is going to the government, what do you think is going to happen when there is a complete stop to it??
I'll be waiting for the "oh, increased taxes wont bother me" argument, but i guarentee, every single tax payer will be up in arms at having to pay so much more!!
Trouble with the tax argument is you can extend it.
If smoking's OK because of the tax revenue - lets legalise canabis and tax it - we can raise even more.
How about cocaine - they're all rich media types - legalise and tax.
It's hard to argue the cigarette tax angle and the anti-drug angle consistantly
If smoking's OK because of the tax revenue - lets legalise canabis and tax it - we can raise even more.
How about cocaine - they're all rich media types - legalise and tax.
It's hard to argue the cigarette tax angle and the anti-drug angle consistantly
Yes jake normally you are correct, but in the case of smoking I don't want to breath their foul *****! Ok I go out for a pint but I don't go round pouring it down the neck of strangers.
ahhh MR Bounty, bless, the old tax argument, complete and utter b0llucks, smoking costs far more that it brings in, try again. Not just the direct stuff try adding up all the indirect costs. OK it would take time to feed through but hey the amount is tiny. Total income from smoking pays for the NHS for about a fortnight. The goverement guarenteed 10 times as much to the banks in surety the othet week.
ahhh MR Bounty, bless, the old tax argument, complete and utter b0llucks, smoking costs far more that it brings in, try again. Not just the direct stuff try adding up all the indirect costs. OK it would take time to feed through but hey the amount is tiny. Total income from smoking pays for the NHS for about a fortnight. The goverement guarenteed 10 times as much to the banks in surety the othet week.
anyway I wasn't really looking for a smokers v non smokers row, I was more interested in the future for smoking etc, will it die out eventually? Will out descendants look upon it with amusement in the future? It's interesting to note that SciFi shows of the 60's 70's etc show people smoking, so they clearly thought it would be around.
Well said, jake.
Nothing should ever be banned unless it harms others. If there's an argument that smoking outdoors does that, then fine - make it illegal. But if it's just to protect people from themselves, that's not what the law is for. That's Nanny government.
I hate smoking, it's disgusting. But I don't hate it more than I value liberty.
If suicide is legal (which it is), how can we start banning things because it's harmful to the people doing it?
Nothing should ever be banned unless it harms others. If there's an argument that smoking outdoors does that, then fine - make it illegal. But if it's just to protect people from themselves, that's not what the law is for. That's Nanny government.
I hate smoking, it's disgusting. But I don't hate it more than I value liberty.
If suicide is legal (which it is), how can we start banning things because it's harmful to the people doing it?
Even if smoking was banned, many people would still do it. It would be impossible to ban, especially in a free country.
No, the ban on displaying cigarettes will not make any difference at all. Just as banning TV commercials, or newspaper advertisements has made no difference.
Only 16% of the UK population now smoke. Unfortunately, the figures of new young smokers taking up the habit is rising. 450 children start every day, and they will be hooked for many years, if not the rest of their lives, so your smokefree utopia is many years away.
No, the ban on displaying cigarettes will not make any difference at all. Just as banning TV commercials, or newspaper advertisements has made no difference.
Only 16% of the UK population now smoke. Unfortunately, the figures of new young smokers taking up the habit is rising. 450 children start every day, and they will be hooked for many years, if not the rest of their lives, so your smokefree utopia is many years away.
Geezer
Actually smoking taxes do raise more than the smokers cost.
The NHS does spend a lot on cancer treatment but smokers still die earlier so they don't spend so much on treating geriatric diseases for smokers
It's drink that causes more damage than the taxation raises - alcohol related accidents are a huge cost, alcohol related violence even more.
I know you're not a fan of canabis users but I can't ever remember meeting anyone who was violent on it
Quinlad
There is a delicate balance to be struck between libertarianism and public health.
It's not in the public interest to have large numbers of smokers, heavy drikers or drug addicts.
Add that to the fact that many of them actually want to quit and it becomes a government issue to try to stop people starting and help those who want to stop.
We should introduce mandatory ID for cigarettes and booze - doesn't matter if you're drawing your pension you still have to show it.
If we did a special one your booze rights could be withdrawn if you're drunk and disorderly
Actually smoking taxes do raise more than the smokers cost.
The NHS does spend a lot on cancer treatment but smokers still die earlier so they don't spend so much on treating geriatric diseases for smokers
It's drink that causes more damage than the taxation raises - alcohol related accidents are a huge cost, alcohol related violence even more.
I know you're not a fan of canabis users but I can't ever remember meeting anyone who was violent on it
Quinlad
There is a delicate balance to be struck between libertarianism and public health.
It's not in the public interest to have large numbers of smokers, heavy drikers or drug addicts.
Add that to the fact that many of them actually want to quit and it becomes a government issue to try to stop people starting and help those who want to stop.
We should introduce mandatory ID for cigarettes and booze - doesn't matter if you're drawing your pension you still have to show it.
If we did a special one your booze rights could be withdrawn if you're drunk and disorderly
perhaps he thought he could fly eh jake:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/northern_ireland/22 48849.stm
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/northern_ireland/22 48849.stm
There was a very funny Yes Minister that covered this whole "smoking" issue: taxation, NHS, health etc.
Funnly enough, some of the "wild" suggestions put to ban smoking in pubs etc have now come true.
You can watch the whole show in 4 parts on You Tube
Part 1
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=ZwZIOePzXls
Part 2
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=y2udBL1R2_U
Part 3
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=-tLbzQCmOEI
Part 4
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=Py2Lyq1E7O8
Funnly enough, some of the "wild" suggestions put to ban smoking in pubs etc have now come true.
You can watch the whole show in 4 parts on You Tube
Part 1
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=ZwZIOePzXls
Part 2
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=y2udBL1R2_U
Part 3
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=-tLbzQCmOEI
Part 4
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=Py2Lyq1E7O8
Jake, have you been in a cave? there are plenty of cases of violence committed under the influence of the fluffy bunny wonder drug:
http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/news/article-233 69774-details/Review%20of%20cannabis%20laws%20 as%20drug-fuelled%20violence%20spirals/article .do
http://www.stolenchildhood.net/entry/cannabis- use-causing-rise-in-violence-among-children-an d-teens-in-uk/
a quick google is all that's needed.
http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/news/article-233 69774-details/Review%20of%20cannabis%20laws%20 as%20drug-fuelled%20violence%20spirals/article .do
http://www.stolenchildhood.net/entry/cannabis- use-causing-rise-in-violence-among-children-an d-teens-in-uk/
a quick google is all that's needed.
Of course with an ageing population the problem of paying out state pensions for many years has already caused the age of retirement to be extended.
There would be a massive financial benefit if the government were to scrap tax on tobacco and actively encourage smoking.
We do really have to act now to lower the average age of death in our country....
There would be a massive financial benefit if the government were to scrap tax on tobacco and actively encourage smoking.
We do really have to act now to lower the average age of death in our country....
