X Factor Guest Judge?

[NoMercy]

I have been thinking for ages now that X Factor could have a different guest judge every week, simply to give an unbiased opinion on all the performances. Do you agree, and who do you think would make an excellent guest judge?

[cazzz1975]

eventually the programme will be more about the judges than the contestants

[pericat]

I agree about Stacy - she should not open her mouth to talk. The x factor next year is looking for a judge not a new singer and the last four winners will judge them

[ojread2]

Cazz, it already is

[NoMercy]

Doc - you're a man after my own heart !

I thought I'd called it correctly again last night, and then they called out Stacey's name to go through. I was both shocked and gutted that someone as talented as he could lose out to a dim wit like her.

Cazzz - you do have a good point there. It's becoming more and more haute couture every w/end.

[LoftyLottie]

Agreed Sine Pietate. Nothing against the girl herself (except that awful, awful speaking voice) but she isn't very high in the talent stakes. The three blokes should have been in the final.

[LoftyLottie]

No Mercy

(just checking that I have not gone completely mad)

[LoftyLottie]

Sine Pietate

[LoftyLottie]

Phew!!

[craft1948]

I don't think you could have a guest judge each week as aren't they also supposed to be mentors......unless you mean as well as the existing judges.
I would suggest Chris Moyles........

[pericat]

I have to ask - what is sine pietate or whatever that is ?

[LoftyLottie]

Sting? He's got it sussed out nicely.

[NoMercy]

I've been backing Danyl since day one. I could have cried last night. I blame one or two of the judges and the media for all the slurs on his character. He was accused of being an egotist, but I never detected a trace of artifice to him. IMO he was just someone with bags of talent and confidence and he acted with great composure and dignity last night when he learned of his fate.

[craft1948]

I've backed Joe from day one and if he loses out in the final to Stacey I'll be gutted.....

[kojak]

Shane Macgowan

http://17.media.tumbl...zdvw1qzqlono1_400.jpg

[LoftyLottie]

Never mind No Mercy - Danyl will probably do very nicely now. He's bound to have a huge career in front of him with loads of backing from Cowel. I don't think Stacey will be in the limelight for very long even if she wins.

[NoMercy]

I meant as a guest judge and not a mentor. I've no choice but to back Joe now, as he is the most talented person left in the competition.

Sine Pietate - Without Mercy (Italian)

I would love to see Vernon Kay taking the mick out of the contestants. Especially the really awful ones that Louis insists on putting through to the live finals.

[TTG]

Kelly Brook and Abi Titmuss would be great judges.

[NoMercy]

Yeah.... in a wet Tshirt competition.....