Business & Finance1 min ago
Scottish Independence Vote Next October?
82 Answers
https:/
Given the result of the Brexit vote, does she have a compelling case? I’d say she does but I guess it’s for the Supreme Court to decide? I wouldn’t like to see a break-up of the Union but it’s undeniable that Brexit has had a bearing on the whole debate.
Can’t help but feel the more Truss ignores her, the more Sturgeon can play on that attitude with the undecided.
Given the result of the Brexit vote, does she have a compelling case? I’d say she does but I guess it’s for the Supreme Court to decide? I wouldn’t like to see a break-up of the Union but it’s undeniable that Brexit has had a bearing on the whole debate.
Can’t help but feel the more Truss ignores her, the more Sturgeon can play on that attitude with the undecided.
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by FatticusInch. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Meanwhile, Sturgeon creates a furore in her remark about Tories….
https:/
She definitely shouldn’t have said it…..though I’ve a feeling she’s vocalising the thoughts of many right now.
https:/
She definitely shouldn’t have said it…..though I’ve a feeling she’s vocalising the thoughts of many right now.
https:/
Hopefully (for them) the Scots will give up on her!
Hopefully (for them) the Scots will give up on her!
murraymints
//She has less than a third of the Scottish electorate behind her.. Don't believe the hype you see in the media. Her arrival at Dunfermline last wee was a truer reflection of her popularity in Scotland.. Drowned out by Boos..//
That’s the bit I find perplexing, the third of the electorate bit?
They lost the vote last time by 55% to 45% but I’d reason that as they didn’t vote for the subsequent Brexit then it’d be a closer run thing the next time?
My knowledge of Scottish politics is not up to par, I’m just going on what seems possible but even more so in the current political climate?
//She has less than a third of the Scottish electorate behind her.. Don't believe the hype you see in the media. Her arrival at Dunfermline last wee was a truer reflection of her popularity in Scotland.. Drowned out by Boos..//
That’s the bit I find perplexing, the third of the electorate bit?
They lost the vote last time by 55% to 45% but I’d reason that as they didn’t vote for the subsequent Brexit then it’d be a closer run thing the next time?
My knowledge of Scottish politics is not up to par, I’m just going on what seems possible but even more so in the current political climate?
//Given the result of the Brexit vote, does she have a compelling case?//
Brexit or not, she doesn't have a compelling case (to hold a referendum without the consent of the UK government). Constitutional matters are reserved for Westminster. That said, it is not unheard of for the Supreme Court to poke its nose into constitutional matters that are rightly reserved for Parliament, so anything could happen.
Personally, I don't see what all the fuss is about. It's quite clear there is nothing for the vast majority of the rest of the inhabitants of the UK from Scotland's participation in the Union (apart from a hefty bill). It was obvious that these delusions of grandeur would follow from Blair's ludicrous devolution arrangements; the Scots would never be content with operating the trains and emptying the bins. I nearly forgot running the ferries, so would many users of them I imagine considering the balls up the SNP has made of them.
If the majority of Scots are fed up with benefitting from the "free" services that an extra couple of grand per head brings them annually then it would be better all round if they just went their own way. It would stop them continually moaning about their lot and it might even get the ghastly Ms Sturgeon off my telly.
Brexit or not, she doesn't have a compelling case (to hold a referendum without the consent of the UK government). Constitutional matters are reserved for Westminster. That said, it is not unheard of for the Supreme Court to poke its nose into constitutional matters that are rightly reserved for Parliament, so anything could happen.
Personally, I don't see what all the fuss is about. It's quite clear there is nothing for the vast majority of the rest of the inhabitants of the UK from Scotland's participation in the Union (apart from a hefty bill). It was obvious that these delusions of grandeur would follow from Blair's ludicrous devolution arrangements; the Scots would never be content with operating the trains and emptying the bins. I nearly forgot running the ferries, so would many users of them I imagine considering the balls up the SNP has made of them.
If the majority of Scots are fed up with benefitting from the "free" services that an extra couple of grand per head brings them annually then it would be better all round if they just went their own way. It would stop them continually moaning about their lot and it might even get the ghastly Ms Sturgeon off my telly.
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.