Donate SIGN UP

Dave Refuses To Answer Questions At Pmq's

Avatar Image
mikey4444 | 16:40 Wed 28th Oct 2015 | News
64 Answers
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-34658759

The Leader of the Opposition asked dave a very simple question many times today, but dave still refused to answer it !
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 20 of 64rss feed

1 2 3 4 Next Last

Avatar Image
you seem to be having a lovely time lately mikey, I'm so pleased you have cheered up now.
17:16 Wed 28th Oct 2015
Not a simple question mikey..........as well you know.

You are correct the PM didn't answer it. Nothing new there then, including previous PM's.
Prime Ministers Questions should be re-named 'Prime Minister Refuses to Answer Questions'!!
Question Author
Afternoon Sqad !

I think the question was perfectly simple...it seems that its the answer that appears to be difficult !
Exactly.

The whole system is a shambles......not Dave's fault not Corbyn's fault.

Good after noon mikey ..;-)
Interesting that Mr Cameron refers to the noble Lords as 'the unelected' - a facet of their profile that doesn't seem to bother him when he is the one ennobling them!
Question Author
dave was asked this question 6 times, very politely indeed, by the Leader of the Opposition. His unwillingness to answer speaks volumes. Given that he and Gove promised that they wouldn't cut tax credits before the Election,
I would suggest that even if he had given an answer today, that it is doubtful whether he could be trusted to keep his word.

In case anybody has forgotten what Gove actually said, here it is again :::

http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2015/10/23/tax-credits-michael-gove-deny-cut-manifesto_n_8367926.html

The extract from the interview is 2 mins long, but the denial that a future Tory Government would NOT cut tax credits is right before the end.

Of course, we can't always believe politicians but when they say one thing and then do the opposite, then I think it only fair that they should be judged on he consequences.

If both dave and Gove had said, quite clearly in the run-up to the May 7th, that they WERE going to cut tax credits, then, as so many millions of people rely on them, its unclear whether they would still have won the Election.
//Jeremy Corbyn demands tax credit 'guarantee' at PM's questions//

That's not a question.
He probably hasn't answered because the position is in a state of flux and giving an early, un-thought through one, would probably result in people of your political persuasion making even more out of it than you are now.
Naomi - ////Jeremy Corbyn demands tax credit 'guarantee' at PM's questions//

That's not a question. //

No, but asking why Dave is refusing to commit himself is!

The answer is the elephant in the room (or chamber in this case) - the Tories know that their smokescreen about higher minimum wage and raised tax threshold covering the difference is exposed as the lie that it is.

Offsetting one financial loss by supposedly bumping up money taken from elsewhere in the governments' finances saves nothing, and the government are naïve if they think the public can't work that out for themselves.

///The Leader of the Opposition asked Dave a very simple question many times today///

Was he stamping his feet at the same time, he really needs to be patient and wait for Chancellor George Osborne's Autumn Statement, on 25 November.
Question Author
Zacs...that didn't stop him and Gove from making their views known about tax credits before the Election did it ?

Not much sign of shyness then !
Z-M - //He probably hasn't answered because the position is in a state of flux and giving an early, un-thought through one, would probably result in people of your political persuasion making even more out of it than you are now. //

More likely is the fact that Mr Cameron knows full well that his lie is exposed, and he doesn't want to be seen to be lying to Parliament directly - Mr Gove has already put his size nine in it by opening his mouth - let's not make it worse!
Why wait when it only takes a min to give a TRUE answer.
Possibly A-H.
Baldric - /////The Leader of the Opposition asked Dave a very simple question many times today///

Was he stamping his feet at the same time, he really needs to be patient and wait for Chancellor George Osborne's Autumn Statement, on 25 November. //

Mr Corbyn is not willing to give the government a month to chicane their way out of this situation, in which they have plainly planted themselves by reneging on a manifesto commitment, and then trying to pretend that sufferers will not be worse off financially.

Mr Corbyn is not that stupid, and neither are the public.

It is Mr Corbyn's job as head of HM's Opposition to expose the government's smoke and mirrors, and on this, he seems to be doing his job very well.
/// Interesting that Mr Cameron refers to the noble Lords as 'the unelected' - a facet of their profile that doesn't seem to bother him when he is the one ennobling them! ///

He was just quoting a fact, nothing wrong with that, they were still unelected under previous Labour governments.
//More likely is the fact that Mr Cameron knows full well that his lie is exposed//

He hasn’t lied. His comments referred to Child Tax Credits. This is about Working Tax Credits – two different things.

Zacs at 16.08 is right.


you seem to be having a lovely time lately mikey, I'm so pleased you have cheered up now.
Would Corbyn answer if he was asked if he would guarantee that nobody would be worse off under Labour?
Good question AOG. I might have added 'truthfully' at the correct juncture.

1 to 20 of 64rss feed

1 2 3 4 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

Dave Refuses To Answer Questions At Pmq's

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.