Nice Witches

[hatton02]

Which, if any, of the witches in these films are considered "good" witches?

Bedknobs and Broomsticks
The Golden Compass
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets

Thanks

[joggerjayne]

Harry Potter ...

Hermione
Professor McGonnagall

[joggerjayne]

Golden Compass ...

Serafina Pekkala

(not sure of spelling)

[bibblebub]

Bedknobs and Broomsticks - she's a good witch 'cos she helping us defeat those damned gerries

[inksplotter]

Miss Price in Bedknobs was not a good witch.

A/ Because she has yet to complete the training.
B/ If you define it a witch as a magician, she was not a good magician.

However she could be thought of as a white witch.

[joggerjayne]

Hang on ...

Are we saying "good" as in virtuous ...

Not "good" as in competent.

[hatton02]

Good as in "not bad"...as in, not nasty.

[inksplotter]

But as I said, she had yet to complete her training...

[Ellipsis]

Loads of "nice witches" in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, including ...

Hermione Granger
Mrs Weasley
Ginny Weasley
Professor Minerva McGonagall
Professor Pomona Sprout
Penelope Clearwater
Susan Bones
Alicia Spinnet
Katie Bell
Angelina Johnson
Madam Pomfrey
Hannah Abbott
Lily Potter