When I was looking for a car (and got Heidi), the Hyundai Coupe was the top of my list of cars I would like. I looked at websites and saw a lot of negative comments.
I took my chances and got her anyway and I've never had any problems with her (well, a flat tyre, but that's not manufactuing fault).
If you've never had any problems, then go with that. There's always going to be someone who will say your car is cr@p and at the end of the day, what can REALLY go wrong with a car under 5 years old anyway? Well, that's my ethos and I'm sticking to it LOL.