I've got the Shine and I don't like it, the scroll wheel is difficult to use, it takes far too many presses just to reply to a text and it doesn't have voice dialling. Looks nice though!
I have one myself and it's a lovely phone, I really like it. BUT....it has one very major fault though, in that the battery life is incredibly short. If you use your phone a lot you may even find it doesn't last a day without being recharged. Not an issue for me as I don't use mine a great deal, but I wouldn't go away anywhere without the charger, not even overnight.