Donate SIGN UP

European immigrants added £5bn to UK GDP

Avatar Image
Gromit | 09:16 Sun 01st May 2011 | News
25 Answers
Woohoo!!

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-13251614

Good news eh?
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 20 of 25rss feed

1 2 Next Last

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by Gromit. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Are you allowed to highlite these stories on here?
great news but that's only one side is there a parallel figure for what they cost or is that net figure?
// Gromit
I had something similar happen to me about 30 years ago which may account for my skeptism of the press.

A chemical factory blew Up behind my house and a journalist was approaching us on lookers watching the firebrigade put out the fire. The journalist asked me if I had seen the explosion and I said no, I had just heard a bang and when I looked out of the window I saw smoke. The journalist moved on and I thought nothing of it. Later that day I Got a call from a friend asking if I was alright, and had I seen the Evening paper. When I read it, there were made up quotes attributed to me. My throwaway line about just hearing a bang had become "There was a huge fireball 200 feet high, and my whole flat shook!" I should have complained to the papers editor at the time but I was just bemused. It taught me a lesson early on not to believe everything in the newspapers.

Sadly, as is evident in the AB News Section, a lot of peOple take it all in as gospel truth.
11:54 Fri 29th Apr 2011


That is from the BBC i would like to see it from a reputable source.
Is the BBC not reputable?
No.
Can We Trust The BBC by Robin Aitken

This book asks a big question: can we trust the BBC? The BBC is the most famous media brand in the world and it is growing bigger and more powerful every year. Its reputation depends on honest and accurate journalism. But this book argues that the Corporation's own pervasive left wing political culture imperils its impartiality. It demonstrates how some groups and viewpoints get favourable treatment while others are left out in the cold. The book examines the concept of 'public sector broadcasting' and asks if that has come to mean simply radio and television free of commercial bias. It argues that there are other 'hidden persuaders' that we the audience should be alert to. Drawing on the author's twenty five years as a BBC reporter and executive, the books blends analysis and sharp polemic to paint a vivid picture of life inside the news machine from a uniquely privileged point of view. It also tells the story of how the BBC responded to a dissident in its own ranks. With the future of the BBC now the subject of a government White Paper, this book will be a timely contribution to the debate about public broadcasting.
"But this book argues that the Corporation's own pervasive left wing political culture imperils its impartiality. "
The problem is that impartiality is itself defined as "left wing" by most right-wingers.
Just like Gromit says about the media.

People would hear it on the BBC and treat it as gospel truth but not anymore.
I think you need another thread to discuss BBC impartiality - there is some chap called rebel-somethingorother that would love to chat to you about it i believe as he is border line obsessive about the subject.

This is a good new story - i would also like to know more about how their taxes have propped up our pension system and their work as improved our plumbing a hundred fold. But seriously at the time (and in some quarters still) the eastern europeans are seen as an invading mass adding nothing to the country - does this no convince you that our great country has always benefited from the hard work of immigrants from one neck of the woods or another - the uk is a fantastic country and is only made better by these invading hordes!
Hi iggyb....RebelSouls is the poster you are referring to
I notice the report makes one huge assumption. It says:

"Britain's GDP grew by £98bn, or 7.7%, and the NIESR study says that a 5% share of the £98bn can be put down to the migrants".

How do we know it is 5%?

Do they have any figures to back it up?

It may have gone up anyway WITHOUT any EU immigrants.

It is a bit like me saying I have bought an elephant gun, but since then not one elephant has been seen in my garden, so it must be because I bought the gun.

It is easy to link two events and THINK they must be related.
VHG

Making non-existent connections is a favourite pastime of politicians. "The Tiger That Isn't" gives a good insight into statistics and 'facts' are used to suit the occasion.
^^^^^
into HOW statistics
Question Author
Here is a different twist on the same story...

// UK migrant workers may flee to German companies
Germany is set to gain the most talented migrant workers from the UK after it lifts restrictions on European nationals entering the country. //

http://www.telegraph....German-companies.html
...complete silence from the AOG/Youngmafbog department, what a surprise ;-)
You need to factor in inflation to get a meaningful idea of real growth. Any extra worker will increase GDP by his output but it dont mean a lot. So you get immigrant workers and GDP goes up in proportion. Doesnt matter if the immigrants have taken over jobs previously done by indigenous workers.
EE are the backbone cleaners/feeders in my local hospitals.....rarely are they seen wasting time chatting in shadows; nor chasing multi-compensation claims in tribunals for racial slights.

They're getting a good footing in Heathrow and hopefully making the environment safer.
it's fullyreported in the Sunday Times too, will that do Suspect? (no point in putting a link up as their site is pay-only)
Just think of all the extra hospitals, schools, teachers and medics who are required to keep the system going. This surpasses the £5bn by quite a huge margin.
rov1100

Nonsense.

1 to 20 of 25rss feed

1 2 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

European immigrants added £5bn to UK GDP

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.