Donate SIGN UP

Please Can Anyone Here

Avatar Image
Psybbo | 18:42 Wed 05th Feb 2014 | Law
12 Answers
tell me what is an acceptable jury majority?
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 12 of 12rss feed

Avatar Image
anyway - I hope you get off psybbo I will pray....I mean otherwise you'll have to post under clinko or slammo and that would be terrible
19:12 Wed 05th Feb 2014
10-2 I believe, Psybbo -very, very occasionally 9-3. After that, it's a re-trial.
Question Author
Thank you DTC
In England and Wales, the judge can accept a 10:2 majority - but he is not obliged to.
-- answer removed --
My one experience on a jury was 'solved' with a 10 - 2 vote. Thank God for it as one guy said immediately we got into the jury room that he was not going to vote guilty.
It was a relatively minor case of fraud, but had it been a serious case in the States, he, the juror, would have been responsible for getting a possibly dangerous criminal off.
Question Author
Thank you all for your replies.
If the judge has given the 'majority direction' that the jury not having reached a unanimous verdict, they should endeavour to reach one, but, if they cannot, the judge will now accept a majority verdict, the judge is obliged to accept a majority verdict,, a verdict upon which at least ten of them (with a jury of 12) are agreed. He cannot refuse to accept one then.

When the judge gives that direction is a matter for the judge himself, which he makes according to the length and complexity of the case and from observing and hearing what the jury says, through the foreman in open court, when asked whether they are unanimous, and he also gets clues from the kind of questions the jury ask and what is said when asked whether there is any part of the law or evidence about which they wish to have further assistance. There is a minimum time of two hours in all cases to which is added time for the jury to assemble in court and withdraw again.

Guessing when a jury will return with a verdict is a dark art but the practice of counsel running a sweepstake on the time, with money changing hands in open court, has been judicially discouraged ! (The money now changes hands outside the courtroom).
anyway - I hope you get off psybbo

I will pray....I mean otherwise you'll have to post under clinko or slammo and that would be terrible
Habeas Corpus perhaps?

Is Psybbs keeping Tony imprisoned?
Question Author
Peter that made me laugh so much, you have to have Best Answer but my sincere thanks to Fred and all
Question Author
DTC, I'm still spluttering here, so innocent of all charges xx

1 to 12 of 12rss feed

Do you know the answer?

Please Can Anyone Here

Answer Question >>