Donate SIGN UP

help with grammar!!

Avatar Image
ilovemarkb | 16:44 Tue 28th Aug 2012 | Arts & Literature
18 Answers
this doesn't sound correct

I found it difficult to ask her about her husband who had recently died

or does it?
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 18 of 18rss feed

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by ilovemarkb. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
I'd take out the first her and put the persons name and transpose the last 2 words

I found it difficult to ask Judy about her husband who had died recently
As above with addition of comma after husband.
It sounds a little clumsy. If rewriting is an option I'd be inclined to put "Her husband had recently died and I found it difficult to ask her about him"
Just my opinion of course!
The sequence and choice of words is fine, but just put a comma after 'husband' and it will read more naturally. We would pause briefly after 'husband' when saying the sentence. The comma indicates that pause.

Imagine that the sentence continued 'but I did'. Would it sound correct then? It would, because that's how people speak.(You'd need two commas then; one either side of 'who had recently died' )
Indeed, because it's a subordinate clause.
Or

I found it difficult to ask he about her recently deceased husband.
Question Author
Thanks Guys!!!
Dont ask me,I'm hopeless
I agree with these answers. If I had read the original sentence I'd have been wondering how many other husbands she had.
Personally I'd have just shoved a comma in after "husband", since I'd normally pause there were I saying it, since the information that follows is additional and the sentence still make sense were it not there.
Ah I see Fred has already said as much.
I would have written the same as wolf but with an 'r' thrown in at the appropriate point.
Just a question; why would someone want to ask about someone's husband if he'd died? You can't ask; how's your husband? Surely the sentence is I found it difficult to talk about her husband, who had recently died.
you might be asking about his medical history or anything about him so it is reasonable to ask someone about their late husband.
But there's a difference between asking something about someone and asking about someone, woofgang.
could it be
I found it difficult asking her?
It seems perfectly ok to me as it is, unless the 'hers' refer to two different people.
"I needed to get a complete family history of diabetes, and asked about her parents, but I found it difficult to ask her about her husband, who had recently died."

1 to 18 of 18rss feed

Do you know the answer?

help with grammar!!

Answer Question >>