Yes ! within the city walls as long as the scotsman is shot by someone who was born within the city walls. Also it has to be done with a bow and arrow. Probably not recommended though. I think my scottish friend was a bit worried about going to York with me a few years ago.
I would actually be more receptive to this periodical question if the unenlightened person who answers yes would actually back up the answer with a reliable source or statute. Not some website that's equally obscure.