An American Asks A Question. Surely This...
ChatterBank2 mins ago
I recently lost my husband ,and felt the need to visit a church,used to be a church goer but the last time was in the 80s, am confirmed always visited on holiday etc. These days due to vandalism and theft you can't just walk in, so I thought with it being Easter Sunday I would go.
I couldn't wait to leave it was like being in an American gospel church, people swaying and clapping and hugging one another after it was all finished, is this what it's like now? I know the church has to move on and be modern, perhaps I'm a dinosaur, what's it like were you live ?
Assuming this is an Anglican Church you're talking about, I think to attract more people some are trying to move with the times - as they see it. That often doesn't suit traditionalists though. I'm an unbeliever but I have quite a lot of involvement with the church and even for me abandoning tradition in favour of what is really 'Americanised' evangelistic overtones is not a welcome move.
While I don't frequent a church very often these days, going back some years I was at one for someone's wedding, and was horrified by the utter nonsense of being told to (don't recall exactly what now but it involved turning to the stranger sitting next to me and something, talking, greeting, hugging, whatever).
My thought at the time, and which hasn't changed since, was what a load of utter guano, an invasion of my right to be left alone and appreciate a traditional ceremony, and the rector sure is hoping to reduce the congregation, and support for the church in general.
Can't stand all this audience participation garbage. It's not what one turns up to a place for.
Wouldn't surprise me if it wasn't even more common now though.
//I couldn't wait to leave it was like being in an American gospel church, people swaying and clapping and hugging one another after it was all finished, is this what it's like now? //
And What's wrong in expressing your feelings in that way .
Do people who go to football matches just sit there like statues ?
I'm sure you can find a denomination who worship in a way to suit you ?
Nothing wrong with the 'happy clappy' church service, they can be joyful and uplifting.
My CofE church occasionally has a gospel choir for the first Sunday in the month family service but the traditional, reserved service is the norm, with the hymns from my childhood.
A 2 hour mass is not unusual for a Roman Catholic cathedral like St Chad's in Birmingham.