ChatterBank1 min ago
Who's For Wearing Face Masks/Coverings?
Should we all be wearing them in public places?
https:/
https:/
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by diddlydo. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
When this was discussed earlier, in March/April, I was probably too sceptical about the benefits of mask-wearing, although partly the concern was motivated by the shortage of PPE on the front lines at the time.
But in retrospect I should have agreed with Naomi and others. I don't accept the argument (at least not any more) that wearing masks can be harmful, eg by encouraging people to take risks, because I don't think that would be the mindset of a mask-wearer; and even if it's a marginal benefit then that's enough. I don't think anyone advocating wearing a mask treats it as a perfect solution anyway. Plus I think there's something to be said for the message it sends, ie: "I care about the health of myself and others enough to be trying to do something about it."
But in retrospect I should have agreed with Naomi and others. I don't accept the argument (at least not any more) that wearing masks can be harmful, eg by encouraging people to take risks, because I don't think that would be the mindset of a mask-wearer; and even if it's a marginal benefit then that's enough. I don't think anyone advocating wearing a mask treats it as a perfect solution anyway. Plus I think there's something to be said for the message it sends, ie: "I care about the health of myself and others enough to be trying to do something about it."
//Danny - Two people ( one wearing a face covering one not) are passing a person who is not wearing a face covering. This person , who is in the infectious stage of covid , lets out a huge sneeze. Are you suggesting that both the uncovered person and the covered person have the same chance of catching the covid virus from them?//
Whether you agree or not, AuntPolly, the answer is “yes.” That’s why suggestions on here that older people should be especially careful to wear one are misplaced. They protect other people, not the wearer. So there is no reason why older people should be urged to wear them any more or less than anybody else. There is also the risk that those wearing a face covering are likely to fiddle with it, thus touching their faces with their (possibly) infected hands. One precaution I do take (because it’s practical) is that I do not touch my face, eyes, nose or mouth whilst I’m out. When wearing a covering when I travel by bus or train it s more difficult to stick to that.
//Also, why can we pick up and put down things in the supermarket but in bookshops and clothes shops items have to be steamed or quarantined for three days?//
I think you’ll find most bookshops and clothes shops have stopped that nonsense (if it ever started).
//Seriously would anyone forgo the face covering and let someone sneeze all over them as it 'won't make a difference'?//
You are taking about mitigating two completely different threats. I would not stand and let somebody sneeze all over me at any time – Covid or no Covid. It simply isn’t sensible. Face coverings are to prevent the transmission of the disease in normal circumstances where people come into close proximity more than momentarily.
In all of this, you have to remember that in the UK at present it is estimated that about 1 in 2,200 people have the virus. That means on average you have a 1 in 2,200 chance of encountering somebody who may pass the virus on to you. The chances of that one person actually doing so are very much less. If you feel happy wearing a face covering and believe it will protect you against that tiny risk it will not do any harm. But it should not be mandatory for people to do so in situations where it has no benefit.
Happy to say that my local Tesco Extra is completely back to normal today. No queuing to get in (the barriers were being loaded on to a lorry as I arrived), no one way systems, no arrows on the floor, nobody barking at me to keep to the arrows, no queuing to get out. So it seems that common sense might be starting to prevail.
Whether you agree or not, AuntPolly, the answer is “yes.” That’s why suggestions on here that older people should be especially careful to wear one are misplaced. They protect other people, not the wearer. So there is no reason why older people should be urged to wear them any more or less than anybody else. There is also the risk that those wearing a face covering are likely to fiddle with it, thus touching their faces with their (possibly) infected hands. One precaution I do take (because it’s practical) is that I do not touch my face, eyes, nose or mouth whilst I’m out. When wearing a covering when I travel by bus or train it s more difficult to stick to that.
//Also, why can we pick up and put down things in the supermarket but in bookshops and clothes shops items have to be steamed or quarantined for three days?//
I think you’ll find most bookshops and clothes shops have stopped that nonsense (if it ever started).
//Seriously would anyone forgo the face covering and let someone sneeze all over them as it 'won't make a difference'?//
You are taking about mitigating two completely different threats. I would not stand and let somebody sneeze all over me at any time – Covid or no Covid. It simply isn’t sensible. Face coverings are to prevent the transmission of the disease in normal circumstances where people come into close proximity more than momentarily.
In all of this, you have to remember that in the UK at present it is estimated that about 1 in 2,200 people have the virus. That means on average you have a 1 in 2,200 chance of encountering somebody who may pass the virus on to you. The chances of that one person actually doing so are very much less. If you feel happy wearing a face covering and believe it will protect you against that tiny risk it will not do any harm. But it should not be mandatory for people to do so in situations where it has no benefit.
Happy to say that my local Tesco Extra is completely back to normal today. No queuing to get in (the barriers were being loaded on to a lorry as I arrived), no one way systems, no arrows on the floor, nobody barking at me to keep to the arrows, no queuing to get out. So it seems that common sense might be starting to prevail.
Latest Posts
Body & Soul7 mins ago
News9 mins ago
Day Trippers Will Have To Pay €5 To...
News16 mins ago
Body & Soul16 mins ago
Who Inherits If Children Are Adopted ?
Law20 mins ago
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.