Donate SIGN UP

Should Male Transgender Prisoners Be Sent To Women's Prisons, Before They Have Had Reassignment Surgery?

Avatar Image
anotheoldgit | 08:51 Wed 18th Jul 2018 | News
32 Answers
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 20 of 32rss feed

1 2 Next Last

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by anotheoldgit. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
No.
They let lesbians in.
The judge who sent a wolf to the lambs slaughter needs to be thrown in jail for a few years himself.

I hope the ladies sue him.
No. Not before or after.
No, they shouldn't.

As far as I know, OG, Lesbians are women.....
No.

We are physically different. What if an argument broke out?

If my OH had his man bits removed I can't imagine his fists would shrink.
I am a little confused here.............a person born a man, feels like a woman and wants to be treated as a woman and has hormones and reassignment would be miffed if he/she was sent to a male prison.
So following re-assignment she/he should be sent to a female prison surely?
But before reassignment the born male should never be sent to a female prison as the consequences are inevitable.
-- answer removed --
Being "miffed" isn't the point if you are sent to prison though. It needs to be accurate still. I imagine these ladies are fairly miffed.
Question Author
I wonder if there were such problems before transgender persons became noted?
Whilst the term 'transgender' is a relatively new word the condition is not a new 'thing' just before people suffered as there was no alternative.
Do I think they should have been sent to a womans prison pre op - no - do I think they should have been sent to a male prison - no.
Not before reassignment surgery.

//I wonder if there were such problems before transgender persons became noted?//

No - before transgendered persons ‘became noted’, they were dealt with by the wider society in an entirely different manner.
"Do I think they should have been sent to a womans prison pre op - no - do I think they should have been sent to a male prison - no."

So which prison should they have been sent?
We only have male and female prisons.....(at the moment!)
A seperate wing where they are not a risk or at risk perhaps.
Rockrose, //Do I think they should have been sent to a womans prison pre op - no - do I think they should have been sent to a male prison - no. //

What are you suggesting? That they don't go to prison at all?
Rockrose, cross-posted. So you think special accommodation, which would entail separate facilities, extra staffing, etc., should be organised for them?
Rockrose

A wing in a male prison or a wing in a female prison?
Would there be enough transgenders to fill a wing, or would there be just a couple of transgender cells?

P.S Nice to see you back;-)
I was asked my opinion and I have given it, I appreciate that we cannot all agree but that is my thoughts.
Rockrose, But how would it be organised?
Should homosexuals be sent to same sex prisons?

1 to 20 of 32rss feed

1 2 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

Should Male Transgender Prisoners Be Sent To Women's Prisons, Before They Have Had Reassignment Surgery?

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.