Donate SIGN UP

For any guy that wanted a cut but didn't want to go by themselves...

Avatar Image
Cowtipper | 00:52 Sun 08th May 2011 | News
34 Answers
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 20 of 34rss feed

1 2 Next Last

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by Cowtipper. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Ouch....
I do find what people perceive as 'news' odd sometimes.
-- answer removed --
From the article - “... The city also hopes to establish a world record for the number of people attending a mass circumcision...”

and

“... In rural areas, the surgery is sometimes performed by non-doctors using crude methods...”


What the hell is wrong with these people? Why do they think that a foreskin is so abhorrent that it requires removal with a knife? Don't they believe that God made man in His own image? If so, they must have a very low opinion of God to deliberately disfigure His creation.

This kind of thing makes me so angry. It is utterly sick and another example of religious barbarity inflicted upon the human race. The poor boys.

I'm sure Mike11111 will be along any minute to tell me off about being anti-religious and arrogant.
I agree 100% Birdie.
I found a website that stated the foreskin as "one of God's little mistakes" what a load of old ballocks. It's forced mutilation of the genitals, gross sexual abuse - simple as that.
I wouldn't call it sexual abuse as the intent behind it isn't sexual...

It certainly is mutilation though
Question Author
Um... just for your info this isn't a religious thing.
Isn't it....?

I suppose I better read the link instead of scanning the link...!!
I've also read of female circumcision. To achieve that, the clitoris is sliced off and in some cases, the labia are cut and stitched together (leaving a hole just large enough to pee through – aren't they thoughtful?) so that when it heals, it knits together. The 'logic' being that if a women doesn't enjoy sex or finds sexual intercourse painful, she'll never have need to cheat on her husband for her own sexual gratification (which is now impossible given her condition).

This practise is carried out because of religious beliefs that teach that a woman shouldn’t enjoy sex but should simply endure it – no matter how painful or unpleasant.

Religion eh? Isn't it a wonderful gift to the world?
Cowtipper - “Um... just for your info this isn't a religious thing.”


Really? Is it not? Is it 'cultural' instead?

As we all know, culture has nothing whatsoever to do with religious beliefs and practices......
Question Author
I researched as best as I can an apparently its like boys rites of passage in other places. Jumping out of trees with vines attached to their ankle, tattoos, eating a deer heart. Stuff like that.
Cowtipper -

Does it really matter where the 'tradition' (if you can call it that) of slicing off a chap's foreskin came from?

The fact is, it has absolutely no benefit to the person whatsoever. It does not mean that the person is less prone to STDs. It does not reduce the risk of AIDS (which is something actually being claimed in certain African countries by certain religious 'leaders'). Slicing off the piece of skin that naturally happens to exist at the end of your penis is utterly stupid and nonsensical. It is a barbaric ritual, practised by barbaric religions and forced upon members of the public by proclaiming that it's 'traditional'.

Putting the cultural / religious argument aside, you've only got to look at the faces of these boys to see just how unpleasant and painful it is.
Question Author
Oh dude, I wouldn't do this to any son of mine. Nor do I condone it. But 1500 in just over a half a day is a lot of boys. The more I research it the more pics and I think I'm done. Its first known recording is in the late 1500's or the early 1600's. They think it might have come from Muslims but other sources say no.
A 35y man had this procedure 3y ago, due to some discomfit at intercourse; the relationship subsequently ended and none has taken its place. I do wonder if the procedure was at fault.
It was done in hospital
Question Author
I don't know what sort of discomfort he was having or how long it would take to heal. Mine was done just after I was born so I'm clueless about having one. I'd say if he was willing to get snipped at 35 there were other issues at work.
The problem with practices such as this is that they exist in the limbo between religion and tradition to such an extent that it's difficult to tell which one is which... well, it's not that hard actually...

An example of this is the tradition of Baptisement. This is an entirely invented religious ceremony that is performed to rid the infant child of original sin (!). It was performed by John The Baptist upon Jesus. Since then it has been a religious requirement for all Catholic newborns to be Baptised (or Christened – the terms appear to be interchangeable).

Now, if religious practices and cultures don't interact and mix together then there would be no need nor any desire for non-religious couples to 'Christen' their infant child. But they do. In their droves. And I believe it's very lucrative.

This religious requirement has spilled into mainstream culture and as such, non-religious couples 'Christen' their babies because 'it's the done thing'. A religious requirement has now become 'cultural'.

The point being, Cowtipper, is that despite your claim that, “... this isn't a religious thing.”, I think you'll find that it is.
Baptism is cleansing the soul of original sin by blessed water on a babes forehead; its also rite of passage into the catholic faith. There is no circumcision for RCs.
Question Author
Its interesting in that the Roman Catholic church denounces it and 85% of the island is RC.

1 to 20 of 34rss feed

1 2 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

For any guy that wanted a cut but didn't want to go by themselves...

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.