Donate SIGN UP

The Military Wives

Avatar Image
andy-hughes | 18:00 Wed 07th Dec 2011 | ChatterBank
71 Answers
It has to be because Christmas is near ...

How else can we explain the cod weep-fest that surounds this rather banal song sung not particularly well by a choir of women who cry afterwards?

It's another in a long line of similar cash cows - a group of people who happen to share a common link - priests / nurses / slaughtermen ... OK, I made the last one up, but keep your eyes open!

Leave out the wave of (from where?) emotion, and what do we have here?

A group of women whose wives are soldiers. Just soldiers, doing the job they signed up for, and trained for, with the full knowledge that they are being trained to fire guns because one day they willhave to fire them at someone, who will quitre probaby be firing back. So it's not a major feat of courage or endurance, or anything except men doing their jobs.

So their wives get banded together as as 'choir' based on nothing more than a common link with their husbands' occupation - and suddenly they are headed for the Christmas Number One.

The only saving grace is that for another year the predictbility of the X-Factor winner getting it - close in front of the sun rising tomorrow - is likely to be thwarted, but honestly people, it's a rather lame song sung not especially well, and but for the hype, it would not be selling anywhere.

OK - rant over ... incoming!!!!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0h39vBsiR68
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 20 of 71rss feed

1 2 3 4 Next Last

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by andy-hughes. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Nope, not heard it, aint gonna listen to it either. Can feel the vomit rising thinking about it.

Totally agree andy, sentimental, tugging at the heartstrings, where it's not needed, twaddle.
Please tell me you're joking.
Actually that is a pretty hopeless request. ...
I'm getting goosebumps listening to it. It's lovely and for a good cause.
I think we need some suggestions for some alternative topical festive heart-string-tuggers:
What about:
Costus Eurolltopolos and the Drachmas singing "Penniless This Christmas"
Well I love it - not enough to buy it though - played on the radio daily.
Military Wives sounds just like St Winifreds "Theres no-one quite like Grandma" sentimental tut...and "Help for Heroes" creeps me out whenever it is mentioned...The blokes are doing a tough job,they signed up for..

Give me Nirvana!!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hTWKbfoikeg&ob=av2e
I was just waiting for you to do that, atrollope...... ;-)
Atrollope's got it right!! XD
;-)@bobthefish....I would willingly support SSAFA...but "Help for Heroes"..purrleeaase...that is the Sun hitching itself to another bandwagon..and much too emotive for my taste.
As an ex-Serviceman I'm fully behind the idea, especially because of where some of the charities that will benefit from it.

At least it's an original piece especially composed for them. Rather them number one than some other repetitive dirge/dreadful cover from that sh!te we've come to know as The X Factor.
I'm not into all the emotion and stuff - I'm only thinking of my winnings....;-)

Hi Erin....
So it's not a major feat of courage or endurance, or anything except men doing their jobs.
---------------------------------------

Totally agreed and one from which they do not shirk, nor expect any special or preferential treatment. They do though have the courage to serve and defend the freedoms which allow us to 'rise and sleep under the blanket of the very freedom they provide'. Some people couldn't summon the courage to walk through a Recruiting Office door.
Agree with Philtaz.

Good luck to this crew that are so important to our troops serving wherever and actually I think AH your insinuations are somewhat insulting to them.

If I was to be criticised recently for a thread (in part rightly so), this one of yours leaves a bad taste in the mouth IMHO.
Well i still agree with you andy :-)
I'll just be glad of anyone other than an X-factor contestant singing someone elses song badly.
I'm with Andy also....

Hi Bob :-) lol..
good luck to them.
if forming a choir, recording a song, appearing at the festival of remembrance service, and generally giving themselves something to focus on for a brief while instead of worrying about their husbands who are risking life and limb, then it's been worth it.
and if, as a biproduct of that, some money is raised for forces charities and the x-factor rubbish is completely obliterated from the charts, then three loud cheers for them.
the 3 part series was worth watching for gareth the choirmaster alone!
lyrics are from genuine love letters, we are reminded!
bit 'school choir-y' for me, but good luck to them, i say!

however, all these things always end up with infighting and personal traumas!

you only have to read about the WI Calendar Girls and other 'amateurs' having overnight success ...
Im with you andy

Regular as clockwork,DTc is swiftly in..no matter how sensitive the topic..to heap opprobrium on someones opinion..and profess how insulted he feels!
Their husbands are no longer serving Eth.

1 to 20 of 71rss feed

1 2 3 4 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

The Military Wives

Answer Question >>