SIGN UP

Trial Procedure.

Avatar Image
Atheist | 19:26 Mon 07th Jan 2019 | Law
7 Answers
Does anyone know at what stage a judge is briefed on the prosecution's case prior to a murder trial? Does a Crown Court judge turn up unprepared? Or is (s)he briefed in advance?

Answers

1 to 7 of 7rss feed

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by Atheist. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
the written statements are known as pleadings
(NOT the accounts of oral testimony whether or not they are pleaded)
and they will have this / these
and they will know the charge - mairder (*)

and their law books-
and in this case the need or not to tell the jury about alternative charges / verdicts ( manslaughter )

they wont know what the prosecution is gonna say until the leader opens his mouth

here
https://www.dailypost.co.uk/news/north-wales-news/alleged-conspiracy-supply-cannabis-trial-6483634

here the Crown opened - and the defence said - they need the attorney generals permission to do that dont they?
( cross border drugs supply - it has to be a crime in both coutnries)
Judge Niklas Parry said - carry on we will see
and on day five he said - yeah they do
cas dismissed

from the article the wasted costs order Mr Barracliff sought was over a million smackers

so long answer for 'yes and no'
( I dont do law by the way)
Question Author
PP I didn't completely understand your reply. Does the judge only find out the prosecution case once he appears in court?
-- answer removed --
yes - he turns up 'unprepared'

that is my answer - I am an OAP and not a judge
yes deffo - in R V Molloy above - he didnt know that there was going to be evidence about cross border smuggling

but I dont think he turns up to court and thinks
tum te tum what is on today - tea and sarndwiches on the lawn or that awful form filling the Lord Chancellor wants nowadays

( but you know he knows things like the order in whcih the witnesses are going to be called)
or she :)

//nor she// - so what? she isnt the one indicted. and if she were it wouldnt change the course of the trial

where is NJ ?

luckily for all - as usual - this will not be acted upon....
we think less than 1% threads actually change courses of action
(you know like - 'make a will' and they dont and never would have)
Question Author
Thanks everyone. Much appreciated.

1 to 7 of 7rss feed

Do you know the answer?

Trial Procedure.

Answer Question >>