SIGN UP

More Proof That We're All Migrants Whether We Like It Or Not!

Avatar Image
Mosaic | 09:10 Tue 29th Dec 2015 | History
157 Answers
There's been lots of debate in 2015 about Europe being swamped by migrants. Evidence is now backing up hypotheses that mass migration has been a regular, formative event.
Coming over here, bringing their farming and their bronze...... Media URL: http://popular-archaeology.com/issue/winter-2015-2016/article/scientists-sequence-first-ancient-irish-human-genomes
Description:

Answers

1 to 20 of 157rss feed

1 2 3 4 Next Last

Avatar Image
There are many sides to this subject when it comes to discussing the current crisis, the way it is focussed on western Europe and reaction to it in these countries. I am not convinced that land mass or population density has much to do with any nation's ability to accept rising numbers of migrants in serious need of somewhere to stay. What does matter an awful lot...
14:52 Tue 29th Dec 2015
Hi moze

it has always seemed tome that a million people walking and swimming into Europe in 2015 was caused by something else than the war in Syria

Alot didnt speak Arabic for a start .....

much ink willbe spilt discussing wht happened and why
Oh the irony. Advanced civilisations who brought us great benefits being used to defend those who want our benefits. Nice argument.
Nobody would deny that many (or most) of us are descended from immigrants (Danes, Romans, Angles, Saxons, Jews, Huguenots etc).

However in the past it has been measured in the hundreds or low thousands a year.

But in the last YEAR net migration in to the UK (up to March 2015) was 330,000 (net migration is the number that came in minus the number that went out).

So that is 330,000 EXTRA people in one year, a third the population of Birmingham.

If that continued for 3 years you would have 1 MILLION extra people, about the population of Birmingham.

And those 1 million need to be housed (driving up house prices), treated for illness (causing longer NHS queues), some of them educated (filling up schools), and looked after (putting up the benefits bill).

Most of those coming here have not put IN to the system (financially), but will begin to take OUT of the system as soon as they are here.

As a country we cant take that level of immigration, it puts too much strain on the whole system and infrastructure.

THAT is why people are so against immigration at the moment.

It is the NUMBER of immigrants that is the problem and it seems to be getting worse.
erm no irony

syria at present is a ruin and not an advanced civilisation
or else I would say ZM "go there and get more advanced"
whereas everyone knows that if you go there you will get shot
I see from your avatar that you specialise in hot air and flights of fancy.
I don't understand what the 'like it or not' is attempting to illustrate.
PP, I think you may need to re-read my post. Slowly.
um yah OK zm
Question Author
Naomi - the subtext of many posts this year has been xenophobic, boiling down to a simplistic stance of brown foreigner bad, white christian good. So whether the most zealous racist likes it or not, their (and our) genetic inheritance owes a great deal to mass migrations in the past, and at the moment the two identified large-scale events originated in the area of the upper reaches of the Tigris-Euphrates (now Northern Syria and Kurdish Iraq), followed later by the Pontic Steppe - let's say eastern Bulgaria to eastern Ukraine.
Question Author
Cheers for the insightful debate Douglas.
I like my hot air balloon better than a load of old bull.....

Your link doesn't work.
Mosaic, you're talking about the Syrians introducing farming to Britain roughly 7 millennia ago. Things have changed slightly.
I'm suitably cowed, Mosaic. Good luck with the sixth year studies next year.
Peace out, etc.
Mosaic, You perceive sub-texts that in many instances don’t exist, so try looking at it another way. Could it be that the people you so freely accuse of xenophobia/racism are genuinely doubtful that our genetic inheritance – or any other sort of inheritance – will benefit from current or future mass migrations?
Question Author
Zac, no, not Syrians, as Syria is a modern entity.
Some things have changed, some are perhaps oddly similar. You talk about current land space being 'full up', to summarise.
'Full up' is a relative concept - evidence suggests that in fact the first wave of mass migration, by early farmers, effectively used up landscapes leaving relatively poor land in their wake. The Neolithic landscapes were 'full up' in terms of resource availability. Life however eventually carried on, and here we all are now. So is it possible that our perception of no room in Europe is either misguided, and will change over time?

Douglas - what are sixth year studies?
Good grief!
Question Author
Naomi - if there's a certainty to be gained from studying the past, it's that everything changes. Nothing is static. So what is certain is that Europe will look and sound different. In some parts of Europe that's happening quite quickly now. And the people who represent that change are themselves not static communities - they too will change over time.
At the same time it's natural and human nature to bemoan outsiders and this can be seen in evidence left as soon as the written word emerged - let's say 2500 BCE -ish as a round figure.
Ironically technological advances were disseminated along the migration routes, so back to the start of the thread, mass migration in the past definitely brought positive changes. And conflict. And disease.
So....we live in interesting times. And we are all mongrels, probably be easier all round if we just got over that one.
//our perception of no room in Europe is either misguided, and will change over time?//

we can of course concrete over more of the countryside to provide for those that some are misguidedly doubtful about. this will of course greatly reduce the land's ability to absorb the increasing amounts of precipitation caused in part by atmospheric warming, itself caused in part because there are too many humans consuming too many resources.
Question Author
Sorry about the bad link above, distracted again
This link should do better, insh'allah as we say in Lancashire

And here's the recent article:
http://popular-archaeology.com/issue/winter-2015-2016/article/scientists-sequence-first-ancient-irish-human-genomes
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R1ffyUFRURk
//And we are all mongrels, //

Few would deny that. It doesn't solve the problem though - and neither does lofty idealism.

1 to 20 of 157rss feed

1 2 3 4 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

More Proof That We're All Migrants Whether We Like It Or Not!

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.