Donate SIGN UP

Of Or From?

Avatar Image
Ric.ror | 08:56 Sat 18th Dec 2021 | Arts & Literature
10 Answers
When discussing the single death (so far) related to Omicron many reports say ‘dying of’ but wouldn’t ‘dying from’ be grammatically better? It certainly sounds more precise
Trivial point I know but just wondered
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 10 of 10rss feed

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by Ric.ror. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Or with...
Or not...
Those who gr3ew up on First steps in Latin will understand
this is the dative-ablative problem

F Ritchie Benaud in said book wrote that dative- "to or for"
ablative - "by with or from...."

vis et armis - - by force and by arms - - usually translated by for ce of arms - - labore et somethinngelse - by labour and somethig else

here we have - is "with" or is it "from" ?

it is VERY important ! - and additionally you can understand why people in past time cut each other throats over
homoousion - homo-what-ee-on?

see - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homoousion

as opposed to homoiousion - homoy-what -ee on
the alternative or second choice

and worrabout 'filioque' - and from the son -
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Filioque

which are old equivalents of - - - is it from covid or wiv covid
some things never change

But he might have died of a Tuesday. (L&H)
Now if it were 'with' ( but it may not be) then you could expect that the deaths would be infected with covid in the same proportion as the population - 1: 60
they arent

if it were from you wd expect the deaths to mirror the growth of deaths from covid fromm patient zero - which I thought was three weeks but they are now saying five
they are

but this is my opinion - because we will know in two or three weeks and by then it will tooo late and we will all DDDDDIIIIIIIIEEEEEEEE!
and by then it will be too late and nothing can be done to change it
( sozza about that)

and rickoi ( you da rickoi on East enders den? ) and Ricky there are some truly terrible discussions on AB already - marked by denial of data , wrong statement of data intentionally, and then crazy interpretation of the wrong data
and that is only from the theoretical physicist !

I of course stand aside - silently disapproving

Me ? I think it is 'from' - I think / perceive it is to prevent people from saying "oh yeah pos but they died from something else....."
( Mathe's category of died cured in leukaemia)

just wait- we will know soon
I bet you wish you'd never asked Ric;-)
I found this summary online, which I find myself agreeing with:
https://ibb.co/dGcpBss
that patient died WITH as boris said NOT from as said on here earlier he could have been hit by a bus died from his injuries but had omicron. no one has been reported dead from it (W H O) yet
I've yet to see in the press /tv how many have been hospitalised, this was forced down our neck with covid 19
i suppose someone wiser on here will enlighten me
Someone could die of cancer or die from cancer since "cancer" is not specific.
Agree with Buenchico.

1 to 10 of 10rss feed

Do you know the answer?

Of Or From?

Answer Question >>