Donate SIGN UP

The Story Of Noah...

Avatar Image
has | 19:18 Tue 21st Jan 2014 | Religion & Spirituality
20 Answers
Are there any estimates of how many innocent men,women & children, who were drowned by 'God' during the flood?
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 20 of 20rss feed

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by has. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
-- answer removed --
Yep, thats the thing. It never happened, at least not as described. But, as story goes, assuming it did happen, god basically took it on himself to wipe out all humans bar 8, and all the wildlife bar what was on t'ark. I have biblical scholars suggest a few as 2000 or so, others reckon it would have been in the millions.

But as Scrivens points out, it is really nothing but a symbolic number, since it never happened ;)

Some discussions/contributions on the topic here;
http://au.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20080509034204AAdSHDK
It was only a local world wide flood I guess. Even today some people don't travel more than a few miles from their home.
-- answer removed --
Say it did happen, wouldn't that mean that the entire human race was started by inbreeding and incest?

-- answer removed --
Any engineer would know that a boat of that size could not be made from wood.

Noah would have to have been over 500 years old to get the job done.

So God said to Noah, “I am going to put an end to all people, for the earth is filled with violence because of them. I am surely going to destroy both them and the earth.''

So His solution to violence? More violence. No wonder religious wars have always been so prevalent among those of the Abrahamic faiths.
Mount Ararat is over 5,000 metres and is a volcanic peak. That would be one heck of a flood. I have climbed to over 4.000 metres and its not too comfortable up there. Most of the animals would have turned up their toes. Quite apart from the amount of water needed, this must be an allegorical tale to encourage good behaviour in the hearers.
Here is the description to show how impossible the whole story is but it makes interesting reading.

http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Global_flood
-- answer removed --
Steve, nature is not concerned with perceptions of blood relationship. A foetus is either viable or not. Societies have introduced the notion of incest being wrong, on the logical observation of the outcomes. That never stopped our aristocracy mind you.
I remember trying to explain to a cleric how impossible it all was but the only point he accepted was the fact when the animals were released there would be no food or drinkable water and the land would be dead for the following 10/20 years.
That's how long it takes for salt inundated soil to start growing arable crops. We know that from the reclamation of the sea in Holland. It would have been even worse for Noah because the land around Ararat even today is very poor .

I also asked him how 8 people could feed and muck out a million animals every day for a year and where would all the plants come from to plant up the world again' . His answer was that for God everything is possible.
Ah but it wasn't salty. All that fresh water diluted the salt in the ocean.

Then all the flood water evaporated away leaving the oceans salty again. Simples.
No has - people have written about numbers and their meaning in Genesis - ie they dont mean much
or they have religious meaning (numerology - seven comes up a lot)

I thought this was gonna be
isnt it interesting how this fable comes up in a range of parallel texts and what is the significance ?

I dont know the answer to that q either
So Noah couldn't be a member of UKIP . Maybe he could have joined the Greens.
I think the most significant fact is that for 6 miles height of ocean (height of Everest ) to be suspended in the atmosphere before the rain started have exerted a pressure of over 15,000 pounds per square inch. compared with our normal atmospheric pressure of 14.5 psi. In other words we and everything else would have been squashed , in additioned to being drowned and asphyxiated. That would have included Noah .
None, because it didn't happen. Its madeup. Its a myth, a story. Its completely unfeasible.
Like many Biblical tales, "The Story Of Noah" is most probably an exaggeration of an exaggeration of an exaggeration of an event that may have happened or may not. For example, the New Testament story of the "feeding of five thousand" is an exaggeration of the earlier story of the "feeding of the four thousand" which is itself an exaggeration of the Old Testament story of the feeding of the one hundred with twenty loaves. With each telling, the number of people fed increases, the amount of initial food diminishes and the amount of food left over increases.

The flood story is no different. It is a retelling of the same basic story, with bits added on here and there and bits similarly removed. It closely parallels the story of a flood given in the Epic of Gilgamesh (an Assyrian work dating from around 2500 BC, almost 2000 years before the Biblical account was written). In fact, the Biblical account of the deluge appears to be an amalgamation of two different tellings of the Gilgamesh story. Some details are lost in the Biblical account. For example, where in Gilgamesh a raven, a dove and a swallow are sent to find dry land, in the Biblical version only a raven and a dove are sent. Both stories claim to explain the phenomenon of rainbows. It was also to be found in many Eastern libraries - fragments have been found in Turkey, Syria, Israel and Egypt. A Babylonian version of the flood story is also known - again older than the Biblical version. There is also a well known Greek version of the story.

The genesis (pun intended) of the story most probably has an element of truth within it - a series of catastrophic floods caused many deaths over a relatively short period of time. This probably happened around 12,000 years ago when a great many people were most likely displaced and/or killed due to (relatively) rapid de-glaciation as the Earth emerged from its most recent cyclical Ice Age. The story was orally transmitted through many generations and ended up being embellished to such a degree that we now "remember" it as the Biblical flood story.
beso The dilution would have been about 50% which means many /most marine animals would have died as well as most of the fresh water ones, for opposite reasons.
They would all have died anyway ,the same as the land animals from the 15,000 psi pressure .
When the water evaporated the salt would be precipitated onto all the land
killing most of the microganisms who were still alive. , leaving it sterile.

Once the water evaporated it would be suspended once more in the atmosphere, ( where else would it go ) making the pressure 15,000 psi. again.
So the choice of death is bing impossible to breath , being drowned or crushed.
For all these reasons the ark could not have been built , and had it been many years before the atmosphere became 100% saturated , then it too would have been crushed flat like every other building and plant life.

The only thing that would survive the flood would be hard rock. Remember also the arctic and antarctic, all the deserts and the tropics would be destroyed and with it the worlds climate.
Surely the Biblical answer would be "none -- they were all guilty of sinning before the Lord"?

1 to 20 of 20rss feed

Do you know the answer?

The Story Of Noah...

Answer Question >>