Donate SIGN UP

A Maths Problem ...

Avatar Image
sunny-dave | 11:22 Tue 15th Aug 2017 | ChatterBank
40 Answers
... today is something of a 'mirabile die' as my old Latin teacher would have said.

I have two sources of income - one pays every four weeks on a Tuesday, the other pays on the 15th of every month - and today the two days coincided - I am (temporarily) 'in funds' :)

But (as I love playing with numbers) I then started thinking about how often this must happen - a simple spreadsheet produced the previous and next dates (just keep either adding or subtracting 28 days to today's date for a list) ...

But there didn't seem to be an obvious pattern - so I had a very large cup of coffee and attempted a bit more analysis.

I now have the period over which the sequence repeats and an answer for how often the 15th and 'every fourth week' coincide.

Q1 : What is the period for repeats
Q2 : How often do the days coincide in that period
Q3 : Does it matter that it's the 15th?

If that''s too easy (hello jim360) then try

Q4 : What if I was paid on the last calendar day of each month - how often would that coincide with the 'every fourth week' sequence.

Happy Puzzling

SD xx
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 20 of 40rss feed

1 2 Next Last

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by sunny-dave. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
You need to get out more...........
Question Author
I tried that - there are 'people' out there ... it's quiet in here :)
42?
Question Author
So long and thanks for all the fish, Jim :)
my brain hurts ... doesn't help that some idiot decided that months shouldn't have the same number of days ...


"You need to get out more"....Barmaid? No he doesn't!!!

I was going out yesterday and asked Dave if he wanted to come with me.....he needed petrol in his car so he said he would drive......
When he picked me up he spent ten minutes in my hall "discussing" this.........then started mulling it over......aloud....in the car......

No.......he needs to stay at home when he's playing with his numbers....... ;-)
Is it a leap year...
Question Author
Sometimes, cupes, sometimes ...
"no he needs to stay at home when he is playing with his numbers". Is that a euphenism?!!!!!
Probably Barmaid...Bliss, lol!!!
The next time this happens is in June 2021, I think.
Question Author
"If I'm spared", Jim - I shall look forward to it :)
Question Author
I have a very powerful calculator, BM ...
No, Barmaid....but it's just as embarrassing when he's following you around B&Q in your search for a brake spring and, not having enough fingers, he takes off his shoes and socks to use his toes for counting...... :-(

Jim...please don't encourage him...... ;-).......xxx
Not enough fingers? Obviously not from the Fens then........
I have three incomes - civil service pension, income insurance and some benefit that you lot that work pay to me each two weeks.

I have them plotted on my Google Calendar.
Apart from leap years there is anothe rpossible complication - and that is what happens if the 15th falls at a weekend- are you paid early, on time or late?
What would be a simple problem if every month were teh same length becomes more complicated by the unequal distribution of month lengths, and with leap years to factor in, the numbers of coincident dates will vary from year to year.
Without any calculations at this stage I would say it happens no more than around once every 24 months
"...doesn't help that some idiot decided that months shouldn't have the same number of days ... "

I expect the idiot was faced with the problem that there are 365 days in a year (fixed because of the time it takes the Earth to orbit the Sun). You cannot divide 365 equally by twelve. Of course we don't have to have twelve months. The trouble is you cannot divide 365 equally by any number except five or seventy-three, so we can have either five months of 73 days or seventy-three months of 5 days. A bit of a no-no really.

The answer would be to decimalise the calendar and time. I prepared a paper on this once. It used 100 days in a year with ten months of ten days each. Each day would be of 10 hours (each hour being subdivided into a 100 minutes made up of 100 seconds). I worked out that Christmas Day fell on June 5th and that the New Year would be rung in at 4:29pm on September 13th (September 19th in Leap Years). With only ten months to play with I decided to do away with January and February as they are the coldest.
Question Author
The four weekly income is only ever on a Tuesday, f-f, so weekends are irrelevant. Christmas and New Year are the only fiddly things, but both incomes are paid on the previous working day, so will still coincide ...
Wow!.....wouldn't a night out with these guys be........bliss?.... ;-)

1 to 20 of 40rss feed

1 2 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

A Maths Problem ...

Answer Question >>