Donate SIGN UP

Scam?

Avatar Image
andy-hughes | 14:07 Wed 22nd Oct 2014 | ChatterBank
88 Answers
I have been contacted in my capacity as a writer to proof and edit a document, and asked for a quote.

We have agreed a fee, and I have asked for £50 deposit.

The client advises me that a cheque has been sent, but for £220, could I refund the difference?

Now, in theory, nothing can go wrong - if the money is not credited to my accont, obviously i send no money back, but something is not quite ringing true.

I have written back asking for a cheque for £50 for the deposit as agreed, and I will complete the task on its receipt, and invoice for the remainder.

the erronious cheque I have agreed to return or destroy as the client wishes.

So - i can't lose, but even so, this is sounding very much like a scam - anyone got any thoughts?
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 20 of 88rss feed

1 2 3 4 Next Last

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by andy-hughes. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
it does bear the hallmarks of some scams, and it does sound odd (why £220??); but can you just bank it and wait for it to clear before sending change?
Sounds pretty dodgy to me Andy.
I thought this was a well known scam and wouldn't touch it with a bargepole. You send them the difference and then the original cheque never clears.
Cash cheque & offer refund after completion of your annual accounts, by which time monies should be firmly embedded. Blame HMRC for delays ;)
PS If you are going to proof read - it's erroneous

:-)))
It`s a well known scam and I think it`s on the increase because I have read about it recently somewhere http://www.actionfraud.police.uk/fraud-az-cheque-overpayment-fraud
yup scambo

must be written up somewhere - as I know about it

DEFINITE scam - really Andy - I thought more of you ! [ Gullible or what ?]
Question Author
Prudie - "PS If you are going to proof read - it's erroneous

:-)))"

Thanks! I must confess I do pay far more attention to my 'professional' writing than my endless ranting on here!!!
Withdrawn monies by client is worth chasing in small claims court.
Should the cheque clear (sounds unlikely) then write back and say you will deduct the remaining £170 from the final bill. This is a very old scam, going back to the days before cheque guarantee cards. You would go into a shop, buy some goods, 'mistakenly' write a cheque for more than the amount then ask for the difference in cash. You left with goods plus cash. The cheque would invariably bounce.
Question Author
Prudie - "I thought this was a well known scam and wouldn't touch it with a bargepole. You send them the difference and then the original cheque never clears."

I understand that there are people who would be naiive enough to send the balance back before the original cheque had cleared - but as i pointed out in my OP, I am not one of them. I would wait for the funds to be credited - which I suspect they will not be - hence my Question to see if anyone else knows about this.
Quiet so.
Question Author
Peter - "DEFINITE scam - really Andy - I thought more of you ! [ Gullible or what ?]"

Please re-read my OP, and my reply to Prudie - I was born at night - but it wasn't last night!!!!
Prudie.
You missed accont as well! :-)
-- answer removed --

//This is a very old scam, going back to the days before cheque guarantee cards.//
This is true, and looks like it's been reintroduced since cheque guarantee cards have been withdrawn.
Question Author
Jordyboy - andy i dont know how you find time for your professional writing considering the amount of time you spend pontifacating on here"

It's just a talent that I have - jealous?
It's a complete scam, very well known, it might appear to clear after 3 or 4 days but in reality won't have and will be returned at a later date because banks are set up to clear after 3-5 days even when the cheque can still bounce. It's particularly dangerous if you take a cheque from abroad as it will show as cleared after 3-5 days but won't be and can bounce up to 6 weeks later.
Question Author
kvalidir - "It's a complete scam, very well known, it might appear to clear after 3 or 4 days but in reality won't have and will be returned at a later date because banks are set up to clear after 3-5 days even when the cheque can still bounce. It's particularly dangerous if you take a cheque from abroad as it will show as cleared after 3-5 days but won't be and can bounce up to 6 weeks later."

Thanks for the additional information.

Prior to posting, it was always my intention to take my cheque into the bank and confirm its veracity, as well as confirming that the money had arrived in my account, before sending any money back.

On reflection - the notion of a total stranger sending over £200 to another total stranger on the basis that they will refund 75% of it drives a coach and horses through the believeability of the entire set-up.

1 to 20 of 88rss feed

1 2 3 4 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

Scam?

Answer Question >>