Search In The AnswerBank

German Control

Do the allies from WWII still have any control over modern day Germany? GuavaHalf (Mon 13:44 17/Jan/05)

Please describe this clip for users who are unable to view You Tube videos, this is for their benefit.

Type your answer here
I want to subscribe to this thread

Answers 1 to 9 of 9

Avatar Image
Skids
(Tue 07:20 18/Jan/05)
No.
Avatar Image
GuavaHalf
(Tue 09:09 18/Jan/05)
Question Author
Thanks for that useless answer!
Avatar Image
MORELLO
(Tue 10:40 18/Jan/05)
Why is Skids answer useless? It answers your question and is to the point. Do you need multiple paragraphs for it to be useful? I would say that the question was a bit silly in itself...
Avatar Image
Johnmof
(Tue 10:52 18/Jan/05)
You could argue that Britain and France have some control over Germany as they are part of the European Union, and as such they will have had input into the framing of laws affecting all EC countries, including Germany.
Avatar Image
GuavaHalf
(Tue 13:34 18/Jan/05)
Question Author
Morello - why is the question silly? A surrender document was signed at the end of WWII the allies obviously had some control over Germany at that time. I was wondering if any elements of control remained. Skids answer is useless because he/she does not explain his/her answer. There are many questions on this site that could be answered yes/no but most people put a little mre thought into thier answers.
Avatar Image
undercovers
(Tue 14:07 18/Jan/05)
ooo everyone back in your prams... we still have the largest fighting force outside the uk based in germany - many more than in any of the 5 or 6 war zones we have some influence in. This is due to the surrender document after the second world war agreeing that germany must support any british troops posted there. So thats some sort of influence and a cheep way to keep our military paid for and functioning
Avatar Image
Octavius
(Tue 14:22 18/Jan/05)

Agreements in Paris in 1954 giving the Federal Republic of Germany full independence and complete sovereignty came into force on May 5, 1955.

About halfway down the attached page you will find the whole history of the east/west divisions, involving USSR & the Allied Contro Council.

http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0107568.html

Avatar Image
bernardo
(Tue 21:54 18/Jan/05)
GuavaHalf - you did not ask for an explanation; you asked for an answer.  The answer "No" was entirely adequate and accurate, subject to the proviso explained by Johnmof.
Avatar Image
jno
(Wed 00:59 19/Jan/05)

European Union countries do have some input into the each other's laws, but it's shared - so Britain has only as much say in German law as Germany has in British law. And given the way Germany and France (and others) are ignoring the stability pact that underlies the use of the euro currency, you might think that doesn't amount to much.

If Britain and the US had any control at all over Germany, they would have forced the Germans to back the invasion of Iraq; but they totally failed to achieve this, never mind how many troops they have stationed in Germany. To me that's the clearest evidence that Skids' answer was spot on: No, Germany is a sovereign country that has yielded only a modest portion of its lawmaking capacity to the EU.

Answers 1 to 9 of 9

Search In The AnswerBank

Latest posts [refresh]

2 mins ago

seekeerz

The KM Links Game - November week 3

in Quizzes & Puzzles

6 mins ago

perdell

a throughly bad lot

in Quizzes & Puzzles

11 mins ago

ruthann58

well good morning

in ChatterBank

23 mins ago

ruthann58

FAO Slinkycat and Jan1957

in Animals & Nature